Better QB: Montana or Young?

[Crutch]

montana

[slacker00]

I'd say this argument is about like comparing Brady to McNabb. Sure both were/are great, but one is just a winner and one isn't. I see the Montana/Young the same way. Put McNabb on the Patriots and he'd probably manage a Super Bowl win in 2007, but woulda blown it those other years when Brady didn't.

[5 star bomb]

I voted Steve Young. I was too young to remember Joe Montana, I only remember his couple years at Kansas City but I certainly know he is a legend and one of if not the best ever but Young was awesome. Extremely accurate and could scramble.

[imgv94]

I'd say this argument is about like comparing Brady to McNabb. Sure both were/are great, but one is just a winner and one isn't. I see the Montana/Young the same way. Put McNabb on the Patriots and he'd probably manage a Super Bowl win in 2007, but woulda blown it those other years when Brady didn't.

Of your 1,872 posts, this is the most idiotic one.