Halladay or Lincecum for NL Cy Young?

[coloradobuff]

Me and 3 buddies do a contest where we each pick 4 players for the AL and NL MVPs and Cy Young awards.

Well i have the 1st pick for the NL Cy Young.

Who would you take Halladay or Lincecum?

Appreciate the help. Thanks.

[Enogsiwon]

Halladay easy.. Lincecum is going to have a "bad" year...

[coloradobuff]

yeah im thinkin halladay too b/c injury concern for lincecum..thanks buddy

[dwaechte]

Halladay because he has less chance of wearing down and a better offense behind him. As far as pure pitching goes they're close to a wash.

[blackbox]

The freak as he is known-what a down to earth person and such a cool person-happy and thoughtful young man. gl all

[coloradobuff]

have until saturday to decide..thinking halladay now..

[Terrapin Station]

Tough call, but I'd pick Halladay. As someone else mentioned, way better offense helping to win him games.

[Jiggy Fly]

Tough call, but I'd pick Halladay. As someone else mentioned, way better offense helping to win him games.

I agree!!

[coloradobuff]

halladay make sense b/c his team alot better too

[jjgold]

Lincy easy

[coloradobuff]

easy? im not sure..phillies going to be much betterthan giants..

[ronald]

Jose Lima

[bobbyfk]

Roy Halladay

[Soxsfan9]

Halladay for sure!

[LT Profits]

Halladay because he will be facing weaker lineups than he did in the AL, so if he was that good in the AL the sky's the limit in the NL.

[Killer_Demo]

tim lincecum...this youngster is skilled

[ehetz21]

I think Lincecum is gonna get injured this year, so doubtful for the threepeat

[ertl09]

pedro martinez

[constrictor]

gonna be very close