We'll never know, But with McCoy I think Texas wins. The Texas D was suprisingly dominate, while the offense two turnovers lead to two easy touchdowns. Without that, I don't see why Texas wouldn't win.
We'll I'm Grateful I had Bama, and a spread saving fumble at the end
We'll I'm Grateful I had Bama, and a spread saving fumble at the end

Who is to say what Bama's offensive game plan would have been if McCoy played the full game??? Damn sure would have not run it up the middle like they did so often.

