Eli > Peyton

[sumtingwong]

Eli beat Brady................ TWICE!

Peyton beat Wrecks

end of conversation

[Amadeo-Picks]

Eli also beat Rodgers twice in Green Bay . But still ... Btw the two , Payton is still the man.

[jjgold]

Eli better now though

[EmpireMaker]

Eli is shit

[EmpireMaker]

Derek Anderson would be a top 10 QB with the receivers Eli has

[Renegades]

Eli better in the big games, thats for sure!

[Amadeo-Picks]

Eli better in the big games, thats for sure!

Thats a different statement and a fact .

[GunShard]

Eli had the better team, Peyton is the better quarterback.

[will2survive]

Eli better now though

I must say, Eli is better now, but those neck surgeries are difficult to recover from. Eli NEVER gets hurt.

[will2survive]

Obviously Peyton is the better QB, but I think that he over-thinks things too much and when you do that, you're your own worst enemy.

[slacker00]

Obviously Peyton is the better QB, but I think that he over-thinks things too much and when you do that, you're your own worst enemy.

He just doesn't have the physical skills anymore. Intellectual smoke and mirrors can only take a QB so far...

[beerman2619]

Eli manning sucks balls. Peyton hall of famer eli is not kids