(can we put this to rest) brady vs manning

[Oasis]

Manning is 5-1 vs the Pats last 6!

The NFL officers need to explain why they always gave Manning the home field advantage. I like to see him play in last December in New England.

[fixxer]

who is Manning? lol

[Mr Handicapable]

Every year The NFL officers planning the schedule give Manning an easy path in regular season. They played a bunch of no bodies. The games against decent competitions are all at home. This year Baltimore and New York Jets cleared the path for him. The 9-9 playoff record shows his true capabilities.

WRONG....the Colts were 14-0 and everyone else in the division was 7-7...more importantly 7-5 against everyone but Indy! Not our fault that San Diego and New England choked at home!!

[SBR_John]

I don't think Manning would be better than Brady in a outdoor stadium in New England. IMO, Manning is a little soft.

I would agree. Brady is a great mudder.

[Oasis]

WRONG....the Colts were 14-0 and everyone else in the division was 7-7...more importantly 7-5 against everyone but Indy! Not our fault that San Diego and New England choked at home!!

Before meeting New England, none of the team they played had a winning record.

[Mr Handicapable]

Colts play in New England this year....it will be 6-1 vs Brady!

[Mr Handicapable]

Before meeting New England, none of the team they played had a winning record.

Who cares...they still ended up 7-5 against everyone else after 14 games! While you're on schedules though...here is something WAY MORE IMPORTANT

Colts division : Jacksonville, Tenn, and Houston....Jacksonville & Tenn pretty good thru the past decade!

Pats division: Miami (SUCK), Buffalo (SUCK), Jets (SUCK)....none of them have done $hit this decade except for the Jets this year!

Put the Pats in the Colts division and Indy has homefield for some of those early playoff games in New England and we win!

[brandon m]

He looked great when the Pats were cheating
No super bowls since Belichchick stopped cheating
Both are overrated

Yeah no shit, have they even made it past the wildcard round since spygate? I don't think they have, and the defensive numbers are really bad the last few years. I'd put a big bet on this, if the pats aren't cheating, manning beats them in at least one of those playoff games where the pats went on to win the SB.

[Oasis]

Yeah no shit, have they even made it past the wildcard round since spygate? I don't think they have, and the defensive numbers are really bad the last few years. I'd put a big bet on this, if the pats aren't cheating, manning beats them in at least one of those playoff games where the pats went on to win the SB.

Manning is not able to beat any NFC champion except the Chicago. He was extremely lucky to win that SB ring. That year, the bears woke up in December to hurt the Seahawks and the Saints. Instead of preparing the SB, they went into hibernation during the 2 week break. As a result, Manning got his one and only one ring. With his playoff capabilies, unless he meet the Chicago again, he has no chance for 2nd ring.

[Mr Handicapable]

Yeah he only beat Rex Grossman...heard that one too! Except Grossman beat the hell out of Drew Brees that time to get there! Its a TEAM GAME....people on here just don't get it? Its not the NBA where Michael Jordan can score 40 and steal the ball 5 times on defense too!

[Mr Handicapable]

Its also not Mannings fault that they got suckered on an onside kick either! The Colts got suckered by the Jets Brad Smith in the AFC Championship too....he was a college QB all the way but they didn't play the pass whatsover! Sad to say that its poor coaching....hell make PManning the player-coach and go over defense/special teams too!

[Naz18]

I guess one difference is Manning was playing in the Superbowl last last night while Brady was playing Madden football. Both are great players and both have won it all. Brady was great when the defense was great seems to me.

That's Indy's fault for stacking the talent on the offensive end and not balancing things out. On the other side you had Brady throwing to Deion Branch and David Givens at #1 and #2 WRs. Brady did more with less and all those clutch games the year they beat the Panthers.

[Oasis]

Chicago Bears are not road warriors in December and January. They are 8-35 SU from 1989 to 2009, beating teams like Detroit (4 times) and St Louis (2 times). They are okay at home. Unless he meet the Chicago again, he has no chance to beat other NFC champion to win the 2nd ring.

[Ace_of_Spades]

I can remove this guy for a small fee.

[lakerboy]

Who cares...they still ended up 7-5 against everyone else after 14 games! While you're on schedules though...here is something WAY MORE IMPORTANT

Colts division : Jacksonville, Tenn, and Houston....Jacksonville & Tenn pretty good thru the past decade!

Pats division: Miami (SUCK), Buffalo (SUCK), Jets (SUCK)....none of them have done $hit this decade except for the Jets this year!

Put the Pats in the Colts division and Indy has homefield for some of those early playoff games in New England and we win!

right but you were favored at foxboro as a road team and still choked in the afc title game. the divisions are a wash. buffalo and houston havent done anything for years. the jags and dolphins were average and tenny wasnt much better than the jets. Its all good anyways cause colts lost yesterday and thats what is most important.

[DOMINATER]

BACK AND FORTH WE GO HERE IS THE TRUTH manning arm is so so windy days outside he is less than average

[BigdaddyQH]

The argument is pointless. Both are HOF'ers. As far as who is better than who, ask 100 people and get 100 different opinions. It is really a mute point. You may argue who was the greatest of all time.

[starzmcalow]

bradyys

[PAULYPOKER]

Bubby Brister

[BigdaddyQH]

Bubby Brister

If it ends this argument, he has my vote.

[vyomguy]

Brady is the best .