If Mannig was black would he get off the hook?

[Tree Rollins]

Lakerboy wins this thread, manning should go down as one of the greatest chokers in NFL history............... but hey he's still the best regular season qb of all time...... has to count for something right?

The guy didn't even make an argument. Go back and read through his posts.

[DOMINATER]

laker I

[lakerboy]

Lakerboy wins this thread, manning should go down as one of the greatest chokers in NFL history............... but hey he's still the best regular season qb of all time...... has to count for something right?

Iller thank you at least you understand sport. You are right i cant deny Mannig reg season no matter what.

[frostno98]

not a fukkin chance- the guys stinks end of story- all these people always defending his sorry hick ass- he hasnt won anything meaningful- another choke job- eli is better

No more than Brett Farve, Tim Tebow, or Tyler Hansborough.

[jgray]

I feel foolish for even clicking on this thread. You should be better than this Lakerboy.

[blueghost]

whos mannig

[Mr. Feeney]

Do you guys not think that the Defense had anything to do with that loss. I can name a lot of reasons why we lost with Manning being one of them, but not the main thing.

Giving the Saints 3 at the end of the half, not watching for the onside kick, only getting to run 3 offensive plays in the 2nd quarter, Freeney being hurt and the Colts not blitzing enough. Did Manning set the world on fire, no. But, he isn't entirely to blame either.

[DOMINATER]

Well, lakker I love your style and swag, but I am missing in action concerning P . M. i am a Pats fan, and really have studied this long tall drink of water this guy plays big, and hes a tennesee strong guy above average intelligence he can make a ball sing, he even runs inside you got me l.b. as they say on t,v. is that your final answer yes

[PeePee]

Manning is best QB ever....


If he had a decent running game and Defense in is career he would have won more rings....imo.


No one can affect a game the way he does.

[lakerboy]

I feel foolish for even clicking on this thread. You should be better than this Lakerboy.

Sorry Jgray i just dont like manning and i am enjoying this

[lakerboy]

Manning is best QB ever....


If he had a decent running game and Defense in is career he would have won more rings....imo.


No one can affect a game the way he does.

For sure - ask the guy who picked him

[jsmithj88]

manning has choked in a LOT of big games
he was lucky he got to play the bears for his superbowl
if we look back on that game, he had 2 running backs rushing for 100 yards
and the bears had rex grossman as the QB, haha

[bobspicks]

Are some of you serious you would think manning had 3 ints in this game he threw 1 pick!!!!
Dont hear anything about the dropped balls or the passes that were pinpoint!!!
Cmon man why does it matter what color his skin is we all bleed and make mistakes!!!
I won 9 outta 12 bets placed on the superbowl I just think this thread is ridiculous!!!
I have lots of respect for LB but this thread was not needed!!!
Never thought manning was great under pressure but he has won a SB and he sure does not stink but he is a hick and hes one of the top 5 I ever seen play!!!(since the 70's)

[BettingWizard]

colts = atlanta braves

one title against a team that had no business being in the super bowl, and multiple choke jobs

[GiveMeaBJ]

Peyton Manning:
-9-9 in playoffs
-2-5 in road playoff games
-1-1 in Super Bowls
-19 post season INT's in 18 games.
-50% of his playoff games he has had a 85.0 or less QB Rating.
-3 games with a less then 40.0 QB rating!
-9 games with a 1:1 TD:Turnover ratio or less.

Guy is a fantastic regular season QB. Best ever? PLEASE! He is a very very very average playoff QB.

[antifoil]

stop feeding the troll

[andywend]

Has a black quarterback ever made it to the Super Bowl?

[antifoil]

The first and so far only black quarterback to win the Superbowl is Doug Williams, who led the Washington Redskins to a 42-10 win over the Denver Broncos at Superbowl XXII (1988). He also won the MVP award for that particular game.

(Note - there are some black quarterbacks who have Superbowl rings for being back-ups who didn't take the field, so I guess they technically 'won' a Superbowl... but I am ignoring these since I'm not sure they really count as significant achievements)


and steve mcnair

[TheAccountant]

Bah Saints won on the onside kick..Peyton went for it and threw a pick..he is still HoF

[byronbb]

He didn't lose this game at all. Saints were the better side.

[ttwarrior1]

if manning was black, he would be getting caught next with text messages to some woman he is seeing,

[THE PROFIT]

This is a perfect example of what Lakerboy is talking about right here. Look how The Profit try and clean it up for Manning with if's and buts..lol. If that would have been McNabb, this convo would have been how dumb he was to throw that pass or how he didn't look the cornerback off the ball. As much as you folks try and knock Lakerboy in this thread, he hit the nail on the head. I'm a Peyton Manning fan but Lakerboy is right in this case.

Race has nothing to do with it dumbass! How many superbowls does McNabb have? Has he been the league MVP 4 times? I didn't think so! I have never bought into the whole black QB is stupid bullshit. People are people, some are stupid, some do stupid things, some do them more than others. All I'm saying is I'm not going to base Mannings career or his abilities in "the big game" on an interception that wouldn't have cost the game if it hadn't been run back! Because he has proven his greatness with a superbowl win & a superbowl appearance and 4 MVP awards. WTF has McNabb proved? I don't think he's stupid, he's just not the QB Manning is! I hate this crap that we're supposed to praise black QB's & can't white ones. There hasn't been that many black QB's & all QB's can't be great so that kind of leaves a small sample of black ones doesn't it? I don't have white guilt like some people! I don't kiss a black mans ass because he's black! I call 'em like I see 'em & McNabb has proven nothing to me of greatness. I feel the same way about McNabb as I do Romo. I put them in the same class. NOTHING SPECIAL

[Jonah]

Brilliant...and since your observation skills are somewhat lacking, I will spell it out for you - I'm being sarcastic.

[Hotdiggity11]

Manning is a great QB and one of the best ever. Brees was better today. Congratulations to Saints fans and the team.

[TGHMak]

What if he was Asian..

[teaserpleaser]

peyton picked a hell of a time to have a bad game

[teaserpleaser]

saints dropped 2 other passes that should have been picked

[tltaylor89]

What is this a joke

[MadTiger]

What is this a joke

Sad when a website resorts to threads like this/tolerates threads like this.

***delurk again for a few months***

[lakerboy]

Has a black quarterback ever made it to the Super Bowl?

No Doug Williams , Donovan McNabb and Steve Mcnair are all white.

[Who Dat]

I get why your asking this. Let me say that McNab gets a pass with national media he does not get a pass with fans or local media. So it is debatable how much of a pass he gets. I would argue Dan Marino has got more of a pass for never winning a big game than any one and we all know what color he is.