If Manning doesnt win is he the most overrated QB ever?

[BigMama]

great day for all

[AlphaOmega]

Peyton manning is a great qb he is not overrated he just had a lot of injuries around him this year to prevent him from having a successful season and kill his playoff run. Next year when everyone is back & healthy they will have a better season

[Capybara]

Funny bump, Laker. I remember replying in this thread last year.

Your argument is actually gaining some clout now that Peyton's postseason record is sub-.500. Guy will always be a tremendous quarterback, but he hasn't brought his team over the top in their biggest games for the most part over his career.

[bruceBRUCEbruce]

Peyton manning is a great qb he is not overrated he just had a lot of injuries around him this year to prevent him from having a successful season and kill his playoff run.

Interesting thread...if Manning is the one who got injured this year, and not those around him, this Colts team probably wins about 4-5 games.

[The Bet Master]

No, as others have stated, he had a lot of injuries around him and still managed to almost win.

[thisisit]

The pressure def gets to Manning. He was this way even way back at Tennessee! The guy is an unbelievable regular season qb, but even when he had an in your prime Edgerrin James he chocked in the playoffs. He is top 15 all time, but will never be one of the greatest

[BettingWizard]

cant say "better team won" and then give manning credit for his only super bowl win when he had 3 tds and 7 ints that postseason.

O-V-E-R-R-A-T-E-D

top 2 in no order are unitas and montana

#3 is Elway

everybody else is interchangable

[JR007]

Always glad to see Manning go home.

not me.....he is a "square favorite"

[Stacocakes]

Manning put his team into a position to win yesterday. It's the Colts D that cost them yesterday.With that being said, Brady is and will always be better then Manning, no questions asked. Manning doesn't even have a .500 win percentage in the playoffs