If you had to take 1 QB that is left?

[Deuce]

Favre
Manning
Rivers
Warner
Brees
Sanchez
Romo
Flacco

Who would it be?

Based on recent past, I would take WARNER.

[Deuce]

Warner
Manning
Brees
Favre
Rivers
Romo
Flacco
Sanchez

In order.

[paco]

Manning for me

[tonyhomo]

i know which one i wouldn't take

[SamsNCharge99]

Manning easily

[stevek173]

I'd take Dirty Sanchez, the kid's got lightning in his saddle and won't be stopped imo

[dwaechte]

Not counting age? As in just for one game?

Manning
Brees
Rivers
Warner
Rodgers
Romo
Favre

[philswin]

top 3 - Manning - Brees - Favre

[lakerboy]

If you go on history there are only 3 choices- manning, warner and favre. They have all lost big games but manning has never lost the superbowl game. I absolutely hate Mannings guts but he has to be the choice. Warner would be second. The funny thing is that i believe in the end Romo and Rivers will be playing in the big game.

[obamaismyuncle]

Manning

[cadillac pete]

Manning by far...Rivers a distant second, and who cares about the rest...These guys are the two best imo.

[Richkas]

Favre
Manning
Rivers
Warner
Brees
Sanchez
Romo
Flacco

Who would it be?

Based on recent past, I would take WARNER.

Not even close. Manning. Now if its to start a team for the future Sanchez. You guys who like Warner do not know football. Sure he's good, but not in the same class as Manning.

[KKoz9]

Manning by a long shot

then

Warner
Rivers
Romo


scratch on the other four scrubs

[tullamore]

I hate to say it, but Manning and it really isn't close.

He has come a long way from the choke artist he was early in his career.

[tullamore]

Not even close. Manning. Now if its to start a team for the future Sanchez. You guys who like Warner do not know football. Sure he's good, but not in the same class as Manning.

Put Manning with those Cards WR and watch out.

[Carseller4]

Brees
Manning
Warner
Farve

after that they are one in the same

[Deuce]

Manning has always had weapons, put him on the Detroit Lions, he will blend in as well.

[pimike]

Rivers (easy pick)

[tmorton]

Manning... Look what happens when they bench him to stay healthy! They suck!

[DwightShrute]

Rivers is playing as well as anyone. I will take him

[podunk]

Manning has always had weapons, put him on the Detroit Lions, he will blend in as well.

ridiculous statement

he made wayne into a good receiver, as well with garcon and collie this year.

manning would instantly make the lions a contender in the nfc north

[KKoz9]

I hate to say it, but Manning and it really isn't close.

He has come a long way from the choke artist he was early in his career.

Sounds like the same rap Romo is getting now.

Looks like he may have turned the corner too.

[bradthebloke]

Manning

[jjgold]

Warner in a landslide, know one even close to his clutch playoff performances.

[BubbleBobble]

Flacco is the worst out of that bunch

[podunk]

Warner in a landslide, know one even close to his clutch playoff performances.

he was clutch in last year's super bowl