Revisiting Kurt Warner HOF question....

[Chi_archie]

if GB comes back to win and Kurt hangs em up....does he get your Hall of Fame vote if you had one?

what if he wins today, loses next week? does that change anyone's nos?

what if he makes it to the superbowl, and even wins? would that put any possible "no's" over the edge and get you to vote for him?

I would vote for him.....

but I think his legacy stands a far far greater chance if he at least gets back to the SB.

he has some incredible stats and hardware, but he didn't it in a different age and system than most HOF QB's

[paco]

HoF QB for sure imo

[Chi_archie]

His wife will insist they make a bust of her too

[Chi_archie]

and possibly Jesus between them

[TobiasFunke]

Only if he wins another super bowl

[Chi_archie]

so 2 sb wins does it for you tobias.... is it because the stats are on the borderline...or are you a big proponent of a hall of famer having championships to truly prove his worth

[Mudcat]

I already had him in before this season kicked off.

[brock]

yes

[lakerboy]

Warner is a hof regardless of this game

[TobiasFunke]

so 2 sb wins does it for you tobias.... is it because the stats are on the borderline...or are you a big proponent of a hall of famer having championships to truly prove his worth

Well maybe its just my own ignorance Arch, but it just doesn't fit right in my mind enshrining Warner with the likes of Favre, Manning, Elway, Marino, Namath, unitas, Young, etc...but with 2 superbowl's it would be hard to keep him out.

[Chi_archie]

Well maybe its just my own ignorance Arch, but it just doesn't fit right in my mind enshrining Warner with the likes of Favre, Manning, Elway, Marino, Namath, unitas, Young, etc...but with 2 superbowl's it would be hard to keep him out.

so you'd put Ben Roethlisberger in if he plays about 5 more years and has the same kind of stats as he has averaged for the past 6....even if he never makes another SB?

[TobiasFunke]

so you'd put Ben Roethlisberger in if he plays about 5 more years and has the same kind of stats as he has averaged for the past 6....even if he never makes another SB?

How many quarterbacks with 2 superbowls aren't in the HOF?

[jjgold]

1st ballot hall of famer

One of greatest clutch qbs of all times

[BubbleBobble]

The only reason why it is even questionable: he plays for Arizona now. Not Indy or any other public team.

[seaborneq]

1st ballot, which doesn't mean much. Plays well when stakes are the highest.

[Chi_archie]

How many quarterbacks with 2 superbowls aren't in the HOF?

Could there be some correlation there??????

[Chi_archie]

but to answer the question.... Jim Plunkett won 2 and he is not in

[Chi_archie]

how many hall of fame qbs DON'T have 2 or even 1 super bowl win?

[dwaechte]

He's in for sure now I think.

[jjgold]

He is one of best QB's ever

Lets not kid ourselves