Lincecum , Carpenter , Wainwright NL Cy Young?

[The General]

Lincecum , Carpenter , Wainwright NL Cy Young?

[daggerkobe]

Carpenter - NL
King Felix - AL

[FrozenMAN]

where's OTHER: JOSH JOHNSON BABY, shoulda had ATLEAST 4 more w's too...

[Cabo]

Carpenter

[azn624]

id go wainwright, Carpenter, Lincecum

[stevek173]

I go with Carpenter...best races we've had in a long time.

[MJFtheGenius]

Sabathia

[oda11]

Carpenter!

[Wilforth]

AL: Zach Greinke

NL: Tim Lincecum

[Ulver86]

AL: Zach Greinke

NL: Tim Lincecum

This man is correct


and if you say Sabbathia for AL all i have to say is what sport are you watching


Greinke's ERA is a full run lower than Crappathia

let me repeat that

his ERA is a FULL RUN LOWER

taking Crappathia is just showing you have no respect or knowledge of the sport and should literally be taken outside like a dog and shot

[Immortality]

Sabathia has no chance. His last start where he got ripped by the Rays ruined what little chance he had.

[EdV38]

Top 3 in each league:

NL:
Lincecum
Carpenter
Wainwright

AL:
Hernandez
Greinke
Halladay

Guys like Verlander, Vazquez, Jurrjens, Lester, Haren, Johnson, Beckett, Sabathia and Cain won't even get a wiff of consideration despite their great seasons. Some years guys who had seasons similar or worse to the aforementioned would win it. This is by far the best crop of pitching performances I have seen in a long time.

[gambleballs]

It goes to Wainwright and Hernandez. Carpenter would have a shot if hitting was taken into consideration after that Grand Slam, 6 RBI showing last Tuesday

[fixxer]

Carpenter...

[lolbear]

have to go with lincecum then carpenter for NL and greinke then hernandez for AL

[jcygts6]

i think lincecum is the most deserving of the NL CY young... but Carpenter will win it because he has more wins

[Killer_Demo]

lincecum

[gambleballs]

I think Wainwright and Carpenter have an edge in the votes over Lincecum since they are making post season appearances.

[Zou_fan]

I echo a few posts above
NL: Carpenter
AL: Greinke

[LT Profits]

Carpenter - NL
King Felix - AL

I voted Carpenter myself.

But as much as I love King Felix, Greinke was the best pitcher in all of baseball this year. He shouldn't be penalized because his team sucks ass.

[DeluxeLiner]

Carpenter wasn't as fun to watch as Lincecum (Wainwright just has wins, doesn't mean anything to me), but at the end of the season Carpenter was a bit more dominant.

Greinke, easy pick though King Felix close second. Sabbathia is pitching in a park that is not easy to have a good ERA at though....flyballs turn into home runs very easily.

[droc]

NL.........Carpenter
AL.........Greinke

[iHaterehab13]

Carpenter! if he kills it in the playoffs then lincecum has no chance!

[Immortality]

Carpenter! if he kills it in the playoffs then lincecum has no chance!

Votes are in before the post season starts so what Carpenter does in the playoffs is irrelevant.

[Willie Bee]

I think Carpenter will win it in the NL, unless Wainwright steals too many votes from him. I stillthink Wainwright was the true horse of the Cardinals' staff and the reason they ran away with the NL Central.

[thekap]

any books offering current odds on this?

[tripp]

Wainwright should win hands down. Wasn't even aware it was a close race..thought Wainwright had it in the bag, just like Grienke.

[element1286]

Wainwright, Lincecum, then Carpenter.

Carpenter had a real lucky HR/FB rate, and pitched 40 or less innings than the other 2, so he is the easy call for number 3, IMO.

Lincecum definitely gets helped by that park, as he doesn't get a ton of GB's, yet still posts very low HR numbers.

Wainwright by a nose.

[Lincecumstain]

I think Wainwright will definitely win despite my huge bias to my boy, Lincecumstain. If the Giants scored more than 0 runs per game, Lincecum would have more wins and be the clear winner.

Greinke should easily win the AL.

[JamesGenius]

This man is correct


and if you say Sabbathia for AL all i have to say is what sport are you watching


Greinke's ERA is a full run lower than Crappathia

let me repeat that

his ERA is a FULL RUN LOWER

taking Crappathia is just showing you have no respect or knowledge of the sport and should literally be taken outside like a dog and shot

thats not that hard when, when your in the AL east your ERA automatically goes up one run when you play the redsox 30 times each

[thekap]

I can't find odds being dealt anywhere (other than Matchbook) - anyone seen these posted recently?
thanks

[smitch124]

I can't find odds being dealt anywhere (other than Matchbook) - anyone seen these posted recently?
thanks

Even though the vote is done before the post season, you probably won't see any lines on this until after the World Series

[thekap]

Ok thanks for the insight. The odds seemed stacked on Carpenter from the lines at Matchbook, was wondering if that meant someone was trading on insider knowledge and maybe that's why no one was posting odds.