Petyon Manning > Brett Favre

[SamsNCharge99]

Manning will break a lot of Favre records. At the end of both of the players careers, I think Manning will said to be the better player of the 2.

[element1286]

He already is.

[SamsNCharge99]

I mean, when it comes down to it, there are 4-5 QBs you want w/ the ball w/ 2 minutes to go in the game or even half. manning drove Indy down the field easily for a TD against Seattle. I know that's just one game, but he has proven YEAR after YEAR after YEAR he is the best.

You can guarantee that he will be getting 3500+ yards and 20 TDs. Never injured and doesn't miss any games. 1 Superbowl title and maybe more to come.

He is the best

[rjt721]

No shit.

[SamsNCharge99]

have to bump this...again Manning drives the team down and dominates every defense in less than a minute

Right now, stats wise, obv. Favre is better, but in 10 years, Manning will be the best of all time

[paco]

What about Kyle Orton leading the Broncos on a 98 Yard drive?

[MrMonkey]

Without question!!! Not even close!

[Ralphie1412]

There is no better QB at the 2 minute drill in the history of the game.

[jhack704]

favre is a stud hands down

[SamsNCharge99]

favre is a stud hands down

what Favre has done is astounding to say the least, but when it comes to the end of both careers, Manning will have more yards and TDs IMO and WAY WAY WAY less Turn Overs (INTS)

[jhack704]

not if favre plays five more years manning wont be able to catch up unless manning plays 20 more yrs from now

[jjgold]

Manning is 10x the player and person Favre is

Case closed

[element1286]

not if favre plays five more years manning wont be able to catch up unless manning plays 20 more yrs from now

, he's lucky anyone still wants him this year.

[jhack704]

thats why he led the vikings down to beat san fran and when gb stoped ap favre threw over 300 yrds and 3 td with 0 tds.

[element1286]

thats why he led the vikings down to beat san fran and when gb stoped ap favre threw over 300 yrds and 3 td with 0 tds.

It's a long season, I wouldn't get too excited about beating the 49'ers.

[lakerboy]

Whats the point. The bottom line is these 2 clowns have underachieved. They have 1 ring each whoopy. Brady won 3 with less to work with. Favre blew the Denver game. Manning beat a Bears team that had Grossman. To be honest here Manning hasnt done nothing except that Superbowl year. He lost so many playoff games where his team was supposed to win. Favre choked enough in th eplayoffs as well. They both are clowns. Last point none of these 2 clowns will win another superbowl ever again.

[lakerboy]

And Collinsworth just pointed out my point you need to win more superbowls.

[SamsNCharge99]

All 5 games for Manning this year for 300+ yards....dude is guaranteed 3500+ yards and 25 TDs each year...man is a STUD

ohh yeah and very few INTs compared to Favre

[chopperocker]

wouldnt be surprised if this was Super Bowl matchup.

[WINGZ]

when all is said and done BOTH Mannings will break most of if not all of Favre's records

[Scorpion]

Kyle Orton > Mannings > Favre

[Chi_archie]

Sammy was 2 when Manning's career started

[Tygah]

Manning will break a lot of Favre records. At the end of both of the players careers, I think Manning will said to be the better player of the 2.

true story

[EmpireMaker]

Favre wins with crap teams and has had the grit to play 19 years I don't see Manning lasting nearly that long even though he has a better team around him. Favre got 10 wins out of the POS Jets last year let's see Manning do that!!!

[Squirrel]

People creaming their duds over Mannings season already? Come back when they face teams who can at least remotely defend the pass. Jags, Dolphins, Cards, Seahawks, Titans - I could throw for 250 against those jokers with a decent O-Line protecting me!

[topcat]

Manning will break a lot of Favre records. At the end of both of the players careers, I think Manning will said to be the better player of the 2.

in my opinon i think peyton manning is the best qb to ever live,and yes i believe he will break favre's record,with the exception of consecotive games played.

[The General]

Kind of like arguing religion in a way. One thing I agree on is that both Need to be on the field Today. I'm glad Favre came back.

[Mikail]

Peyton Manning>Brett Favre.

[thejrichshow85]

no one will break faves records....manning would have to play 10 + years without injury to beat bretts td passes recored and brett still has this year and next year to add on !

favre4life

[xxxvince]

just like everyone thinks arod gonna break barry bonds record, here we go.. another prediction. i will check on this thread in 5.. to 7 years to bother abt any stats. manning is better than favre but favre will end up having all the stats and records.

[textbook winner]

favre didn't have the offense that manning has had to say that manning is better by yards and tds is kinda silly

[tripp]

Without question. Peyton is the greatest player of all time IMO

[BobHarvey]

Both are great QB's. Favre gets the nod for the longetivity factor.

[malay76]

way better

[tripp]

Favre wins with crap teams and has had the grit to play 19 years I don't see Manning lasting nearly that long even though he has a better team around him. Favre got 10 wins out of the POS Jets last year let's see Manning do that!!!

As a Jets fan I can honestly say Favre was the reason the Jets didn't win MORE games last year. He cost them the playoffs, and the players called him out on it after the season ended. That's the reason he was so quick to retire, because he didn't want to come back to the Jets where he knew he wasn't wanted.

I feel more comfortable with Sanchez behind center of my Jets than I did with Favre.

Favre has taken on a better roll with the Vikings though. He has finally realized he is not the star anymore and is playing a role rather than trying to be the hero. Might just be a matter of time before the hero in him comes out and he ends up costing his team with INT's, but we'll see.