Wiil Eli win more Superbowls than Peyton?

DacBietViet · 09-21-09, 11:06 PM

How many polls are you gonna make about these 2. Jeez

lakerboy · 09-21-09, 11:07 PM

10 more than threads you have made

nohuddleoffense · 09-21-09, 11:10 PM

Eli Manning will never win another superbowl, so I'll give it to Peyton because he could win another superbowl possibly.

Jshap1515 · 09-21-09, 11:28 PM

Without a star receiver and losing Derrick Ward, Eli won't be able to carry the team while Peyton just showed he can carry his team.

Seattle Slew · 09-21-09, 11:56 PM

I don't think either one will win another one. Eli, because he's not good enough, and Peyton because his defense absolutely sucks.

Shortstop · 09-22-09, 01:28 AM

Lakes, you have man crushes on the Manning brothers?

GiveMeaBJ · 09-22-09, 01:45 AM

Originally posted by Jshap1515

Without a star receiver and losing Derrick Ward, Eli won't be able to carry the team while Peyton just showed he can carry his team.

Losing Derrick Ward? Who the **** cares. That guy was a bum. Yea he ran for 1,000 yards but if Bradshaw was in there he would have had 1,300+ if given the same amount of carries. Derrick Ward is very, very average.

On topic, Eli will win more Super Bowls. He has a running game and defense which is crucial in the playofffs. Also has a coach. No more Dungy=no more rings. Plus the Giants have to go through a modest NFC and Colts have to deal with AFC.

lys3rg0 · 09-22-09, 05:03 AM

why does the poll have no odds?

jackpot269 · 09-22-09, 06:06 AM

Both =

TheChariot · 09-22-09, 02:35 PM

Can you please add Archie to the poll?

Thanks!

MJFtheGenius · 09-22-09, 02:38 PM

Giants have the better team

slacker00 · 09-23-09, 04:09 AM

Originally posted by Seattle Slew

I don't think either one will win another one. Eli, because he's not good enough, and Peyton because his defense absolutely sucks.

This is the best answer. It's tough to win a SB. It takes a perfect storm of luck & skill.

Originally posted by GiveMeaBJ

On topic, Eli will win more Super Bowls. He has a running game and defense which is crucial in the playofffs. Also has a coach. No more Dungy=no more rings. Plus the Giants have to go through a modest NFC and Colts have to deal with AFC.

Good points. The road is definitely easier for Eli. Plus, Eli probably has many more seasons left than P.

Originally posted by MJFtheGenius

Giants have the better team

Yep. Put Eli on the Colts and Peyton on the Giants and think for a second. Giants are a better team.

ZBOIZ · 09-23-09, 12:06 PM

The Giants will lose to my Saints in the playoffs