Eli v Peyton

[lakerboy]

If you had to pick which one you would have to lead your team to a winning sb drive who would you take?



Eli- been there done that

Peyton- yeah i beat the grossmanplease vote but dont vote for manning

[nohuddleoffense]

Peyton Manning without question, Eli was tossing up presents to Asante Samuel in his game winning drive too bad Asante's got butterfingers. Amani Toomer pulling miracles, drive didn't impress me so much. Peyton Manning 2 minute drive= money in the bank

[lakerboy]

Peyton Manning without question, Eli was tossing up presents to Asante Samuel in his game winning drive too bad Asante's got butterfingers. Amani Toomer pulling miracles, drive didn't impress me so much. Peyton Manning 2 minute drive= money in the bank

which one cause none mattered except the pats game

[Seattle Slew]

Peyton Manning without question, Eli was tossing up presents to Asante Samuel in his game winning drive too bad Asante's got butterfingers. Amani Toomer pulling miracles, drive didn't impress me so much. Peyton Manning 2 minute drive= money in the bank

[nohuddleoffense]

Wait untill the next one that matters, we'll see that crybaby manning fall apart with his security blanket imprisoned, and Peyton will shine. It's inevitable

[colt29]

what does that mean??? Dolphins are a joke

[tacomax]

which one cause none mattered except the pats game

?????

[Jshap1515]

This isnt even close. Peyton Manning is #6 in wins for a reason

[jsmithj88]

eli isnt even in the conversation
is he even a top 10 QB?

[nohuddleoffense]

top 10 QBs

Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Ben Roethlisberger, Philip Rivers, Donovan Mcnabb, Carson Palmer, Tony Romo, Drew Brees, Kurt Warner, Jay Cutler, maybe Brett Favre. All quarterbacks I'd take over Eli Manning so yeah I don't see him as top 10 quarterback

[DacBietViet]

[jsmithj88]

top 10 QBs Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Ben Roethlisberger, Philip Rivers, Donovan Mcnabb, Carson Palmer, Tony Romo, Drew Brees, Kurt Warner, Jay Cutler, maybe Brett Favre. All quarterbacks I'd take over Eli Manning so yeah I don't see him as top 10 quarterback

romo is more overrated than eli
i would rather have eli than romo

[nohuddleoffense]

Romo is deffinently overrated I agree. I'd still take him over Eli though. I might take Matt Ryan over either of them, books still open on him though, I'll see after the conclusion of this season.

[Metalhead]

top 10 QBs

Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Ben Roethlisberger, Philip Rivers, Donovan Mcnabb, Carson Palmer, Tony Romo, Drew Brees, Kurt Warner, Jay Cutler, maybe Brett Favre. All quarterbacks I'd take over Eli Manning so yeah I don't see him as top 10 quarterback

I'd take Eli over Mcnabb, Palmer, Romo and current edition of Favre. A few years ago I had a different opinion of him, but he has proven to be a winner and works with what he has.

[jsmithj88]

I'd take Eli over Mcnabb, Palmer, Romo and current edition of Favre. A few years ago I had a different opinion of him, but he has proven to be a winner and works with what he has.

i disagree with him being better than mcnabb for now
mcnabb has never had anything on offense (other than this year and 1 year with TO)
manning is supported by a great defense and great running game
if he can do well this year i may change my mind since he has no #1 WR

[nohuddleoffense]

McNabb = most underrated quarterback in the NFL by far

[DeeWizzle]

I vote for Manning

[jsmithj88]

Romo is deffinently overrated I agree. I'd still take him over Eli though. I might take Matt Ryan over either of them, books still open on him though, I'll see after the conclusion of this season.

if u want to take some1 who cant even win a playoff game over eli go ahead
romo is like brett favre in his last couple years at GB
just throwing balls up and a turnover machine
this is a big year for both romo and eli b/c neither have a #1 reciever (unless u count roy williams, haha)

[jsmithj88]

McNabb = most underrated quarterback in the NFL by far

i think u meant romo

[nohuddleoffense]

i think u meant romo

I said underrated not overrated

[jsmithj88]

I said underrated not overrated

haha, my fault
u are correct in that case

[seanjohn007]

top 10 QBs

Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Ben Roethlisberger, Philip Rivers, Donovan Mcnabb, Carson Palmer, Tony Romo, Drew Brees, Kurt Warner, Jay Cutler, maybe Brett Favre. All quarterbacks I'd take over Eli Manning so yeah I don't see him as top 10 quarterback

you must be extremely drunk

and if your talking about this years favre, your even more drunk (im going to assume/hope your talking about the old favre)

i could complain 3 or 4 other names on your list, but ill let you off easy

[lys3rg0]

i'll take eli at anything over +400

[tacomax]

please vote but dont vote for manning

Bit difficult. Great thread otherwise.