List the most over rated NFL QB and the most under rated QB

[konck]

MOst over Rated QB Hands down ELI highest paid give me a break he can't even throw a spiral
Most under rated Stump the Schaub for Houston he can throw it

[element1286]

Underrated: Matt Schaub
Overrated: Philip Rivers

[paco]

Overrated: Tony Romo
Underrated: JAke Delhomme

[Jimmy0607]

Overrated: Matt Ryan
Underrated: Matt Schaub

[MilfDriller]

Giving you a pt b/c I liked your previous avatar of 'get that sh*t outta here'

where'd it go?

[MilfDriller]

before you ask about my avatar.. let me tell you that it is 'zoologically correct'

[pavyracer]

overrated: Jay Cutler
underrated: Kurt Warner

[head_strong]

overrated: Jay Cutler
underrated: Kurt Warner

Agree.....

[showtime2000]

Underrated......Drew Brees

[MilfDriller]

That was a great post. Cutler all the way.

Compare Plummer and Cutler in Denver. Plummer was crazy, but he got great results. Cutler couldn't even take his team to the playoffs.

[durito]

That was a great post. Cutler all the way.

Compare Plummer and Cutler in Denver. Plummer was crazy, but he got great results. Cutler couldn't even take his team to the playoffs.

you might be the dumbest mother ****er in the history of life


last years denver defense had the 2nd worst dvoa ever

cutlers 2 year most similars are montana, manning, favre, and brady

but, hey keep betting on that bs espn shit

[MilfDriller]

aw, poor baby, durito. can't believe you finally made a post about sports, you sick fvck.

Remind me again how many times Cutler has led the Broncos to the playoffs?

What was Plummer's winning % in Denver? How many playoff games did he play in?

If you think you're Jesus Christ, post a pick you coward.

[durito]

results oriented thinking at it's best

[BGboothA]

Overrated = Matt Cassell
Underrated = Trent Edwards
Overpaid = Eli Manning

[Team Myers]

Overrated = Carson Palmer
Underrated = Joe Flacco

[seaborneq]

Overrated=Jake Delhomme
Underrated=Big Ben Rothlesburger

[paco]

Overrated=Jake Delhomme
Underrated=Big Ben Rothlesburger

Jake Delhomme is Underrated, he has an awesome arm and very good pocket sense. Just had his worse career game NFC championship

[lakerboy]

Underrated=pennington
Overrated=peyton

[4TH AND STUPID]

overrated = kyle orton [how the hell is he an NFL starting quarterback on any team ?], carson palmer

underrated = matt schaub/matt ryan

terrible 2009 starting quarterbacks / will get exposed = kerry collins/ kyle orton

most likely to shock the world as super bowl winning quarterback = vince young [ the titans are going to the superbowl.. you heard it here first..]

[paco]

Carolina Panthers will win the Championship . Deangelo Williams Superbowl MVP

[lakerboy]

Carolina Panthers will win the Championship . Deangelo Williams Superbowl MVP

Paco u bastard u lied to me you said you were drinking gatorade now I know ur drunk

[rezkoness69]

Overrated: Phillip Rivers
Underrated: Drew Brees....one of the most productive QBs in his time...last year he had the 2nd most passing yards in a single season in NFL history, nobody seems to talk about that

while I agree that eli is a bit overrated, he has led his team to the playoffs every year hes been a starter and won a super bowl. He has played on some good teams, but he won that bowl.

[paco]

Paco u bastard u lied to me you said you were drinking gatorade now I know ur drunk

Lb, trust me wen I tell u DWill is going to have an awesome year. If u play fantasy football, draft him, u won't regret it

[lakerboy]

Lb, trust me wen I tell u DWill is going to have an awesome year. If u play fantasy football, draft him, u won't regret it

Ur right he is good but panthers will NOT be in the dance party

[FrozenMAN]

overrated: brady, just not a fan whatsoever, and comes off to me as a cheating crybaby just like belicheck

underrated: jeff garcia, wins no matter where he goes and can learn any system, i wish my bucs kept him

[ATB515]

Overrated: It's a tie between ShEli Manning, Jay CUNTler, and Big Rapist Roethlisberger
Underrated: Philip Rivers. A fukkin warrior and a natural born leader. Plays on a fukkin Torn ACL. Stat wise, he is one of the best. Doesn't have the luxury of playing on a team with a great defense like the 2 retards that were drafted the same year as him. If he was the QB for the Steelers, he would have 2 rings and ESPN would be sucking his dick every other night like they do with Big Rapist. The Same goes for Drew Brees

[lakerboy]

Overrated: It's a tie between ShEli Manning, Jay CUNTler, and Big Rapist Roethlisberger
Underrated: Philip Rivers. A fukkin warrior and a natural born leader. Plays on a fukkin Torn ACL. Stat wise, he is one of the best. Doesn't have the luxury of playing on a team with a great defense like the 2 retards that were drafted the same year as him. If he was the QB for the Steelers, he would have 2 rings and ESPN would be sucking his dick every other night like they do with Big Rapist. The Same goes for Drew Brees

Unreal I hate ben too but did u know that sd has had one of the top defenses in football for 3 seasons

[paco]

And Phillip had the best rb in LT, so he always had the option for a chekdown and let LT do what he does to take pressure off of him

[ATB515]

More like average. SD has never had a defense like Pittsburgh of last year

Unreal I hate ben too but did u know that sd has had one of the top defenses in football for 3 seasons

[MickChunky]

Under: Schaub, when he's healthy look at his numbers
Over: Vick, when he's not in jail look at his numbers

[rake922]

Underrated: Tom Brady
Overrated: Delhomme

[4TH AND STUPID]

Jay CUNTler

... jay cuntler... i will not forget that nickname..

[brooks85]

.

[Bread]

Overrated: Randall Cunningham
Underrated: Brad Johnson

[MexicanStallion]

Overrated: Carson Palmer
Underrated: Drew Brees