Why don't the Raiders sign Peyton Manning?

[juicername]

What's David Carr up to these days? Seems natural to replace one Carr with another.

[stevek173]

Giant and I don't always get along but he does have a very good point here.

They do that and it could be a superbowl real quick.

It's true.

I didn't have time to even think of that.

Very sharp post.

Even Romo would make sense there.

[ChuckyTheGoat]

Bernie kosar??

doug flutie??

im sure hasselback wants in

Matt? Or Tim?

[jimminn]

I think that Conner Cook will be OK. Let him practice with the starters this week and I believe he will do OK. Raiders will surprise Houston and win.

[sandos139]

Cook looked good today and the raider defense could not back him

Actually he didn't look bad at all for no reps all year. Were going with Cook imo. If the raider D shows up and its not McGloin, were more than capable of beating the Texans.

[readytowinem]

He should be good for a couple of games, no?

If not him, how about Johnny Manziel?

It's a shame that their season is going to end this way. They literally have no quarterbacks, might as well throw one of these guys in there.

Peyton is done. He would hurt more than help.

Maziel is literally a crack head now. All he cares about is partying and doing drugs.

Unfortunately they are done for. It was bad luck, but could of been prevented. They should of been running the ball and not trying to pass. Raiders are like the Clippers, just when you think they might make some noise, something happens.

[chaka]

Sign Mark Wahlberg.

He played QB for the Eagles, has fought in Afghanistan, has battled Transformers and he has a big dik.

Wouldn't be a bad move.

and he talks to animals lol love that snl skit

[TheMoneyShot]

How can you not like Carr? The guy is awesome.
Money, 2017 is not off to a good start for you.

He'll end up just like his brother. Let's face it... you have decent talent... great WR's great RB's. An average QB makes you look like the BEST QB. Cook will do just fine against Houston.

As for Carr's future... guy will fall off the map. Reminds me of a young Carson Palmer. Not saying much. Guy doesn't make "amazing" plays like a QB should. Oh... and you can't be injury prone either.

Moneyshotter drunk again. Carr is a great talent and carries that team to so many comeback road wins

I should be drinking.

Cook looked good today and the raider defense could not back him

Right on. Cook will give you 1 win. Might turn into a Tom Brady. You never know.

Raiders will kill the Texans

Hit the nail on the head.

[Philmill]

Oakland will show up in Houston......Cook looked good under center .......Oakland should win............!

[sweethook]

t e b o w

[gilbert91016]

Do we hammer Houston -3.5???

[recon1]

Kordell Stewart? He's mobile

[The Giant]

I just heard that the Raiders contacted Vinny Testaverde about trying out this week.

[onoon14]

Yea nfl playbooks are pretty easy to learn.

[StatePenn]

JaMarcus Russell is willing to sign and play for free! Kyle Boller too.

[t-wizzle]

Sign manning to do what? He was awful last year. Was never good in the playoffs even in his prime.

[Wrongside]

Not happy about the utter disrespect towards Peyton, Manziel -- or Tebow for that matter.

Guys, there are QB's that can do something as far as helping your team win a playoff game, and there are guys who we know are just too small in big moments - and you are essentially just waiting for your team to lose. I'm not talking about chokers, but more so those 2nd string QB's that don't bring anything to the table for a playoff game.

Hence, why Vinny Testaverde was a good call ( not for this year obviously), but how many times did that guy get brought back, because he can actually do something.

Manziel would not be a bad call, if he weren't a partying stick.

[Wrongside]

Manning's arm was always a lot stronger after rest last year. He has had a lot of rest. Maybe Cook for AFC Championship Game. Carr back for Superbowl.

[Str8Mush4Life]

He was worthless in his prime.

But you originally suggested Johnny Manziel and I think you were serious.............

[stevek173]

I think they should get Brady

That guy is good.

[will2survive]

He should be good for a couple of games, no?

If not him, how about Johnny Manziel?


It's a shame that their season is going to end this way. They literally have no quarterbacks, might as well throw one of these guys in there.

Are you joking? Did you see Peyton Manning in Super Bowl 50??? He was a disaster!! As for Manziel, he made a good move by going to the Heisman Awards and that's a step in the right direction, but he need's to get his life together. The Raiders, if they were even allowed to, should get some veteran quarterback like a Steve DeBerg or Vinny Testaverde back in the day (not those players but the equivalent in 2017). The veteran QB won't win the game, but their experience alone could make them competitive.

It's awful. Derek Carr was going to be the best QB in Raiders history (no offense to Stabler,Plunkett, and Lamonica), but this guy is a stud. The injury happened during a storybook season, but injuries are part of the game. Arizona had a great season two years ago and their top two QB's got injured.

[Cuse0323]

No need to continue discussion. Garrett Gilbert it is.

[batt33]

Heard another Fresno state QB.....................Trent Dilfer ( a proven sb winner) is coming to raider nation

[SEAHAWKHARRY]

Bernie kosar??

doug flutie??

im sure hasselback wants in

Matt Hasselbeck was bad ass as a backup..still could

[Axman3000]

How about Jimmy Clausen? Have to be realistic here, he has experience along with him being under 30. The guy isn't good but will probably be better than a new QB that is starting his first game in the playoffs.

[turtlejc]

you bumped a 3 day old thread to bring up The Pickle?

Cmon guy

[RavensFan2k3]

Is this a serious question?

[Cuse0323]

Connor Cook, that's my Quarterback man.

[INVEGA MAN]

6-2 final

[winitall]

Because he's sucks