Greatest Hitter To Ever Live

[jjgold]

[Jayvegas420]

Agreed

[DOM_Toretto]

That's not Ty Cobb...

[jjgold]

Guys this is a classic

[Ghenghis Kahn]

he's not even top 20 if you count stats...

[lakerboy]

Lol. Won nothing and lost it all. Loser.

[STAX]

Not counting steriods:

1. Babe Ruth
2. Ted Williams
3. Barry Bonds
4. Ty Cobb
5. Albert Pujols
6. Rogers Hornsby
7. Alex Rodriguez
8. Willie Mays
9. Hank Aaron
10. Tony Gwynn

[DOM_Toretto]

Pujols #5?!

Not even best in his era.

Cabrera.

[lakerboy]

Lol rookies here. The toughest out in baseball was Wade Boggs. He hardly struck out and got on base nearly twice the league average.

[Big Bear]

[Jeffie]

Pujols #5?!

Not even best in his era.

Cabrera.

I'm assuming you're just being a homer but Pujols on the cards was 5x better than Cabrera ever was.

[tyrephd]

Charlie Hustle gotta be on the list......

[sourtwist]

Not counting steriods:

1. Babe Ruth
2. Ted Williams
3. Barry Bonds
4. Ty Cobb
5. Albert Pujols
6. Rogers Hornsby
7. Alex Rodriguez
8. Willie Mays
9. Hank Aaron
10. Tony Gwynn

Stax, there is no way you can safely assume that none of those guys used anything to gain an edge. Barry Bonds is the greatest hitter ever.

[packerd_00]

That's not Ty Cobb...

Excatly

[Chi_archie]

Everyone always forgets poor Stan Musial

[MoMoneyMoVaughn]

Where is Lou Gherig?

[CWD]

Barry Bonds holds the Major League Baseball home run record with 762.

[CappinTerp]

Ted Williams or Stan the man!!!.......Never forget Chico Escuela!!!!

[Chi_archie]

stan with 3 MVP's and 4 2nd places in MVP voting

1.	Barry Bonds (7 wins)	9.30	1.	Roger Clemens (7 wins)	7.66
2.	Stan Musial* (3 wins)	6.96	2.	Randy Johnson* (5 wins)	6.50
3.	Albert Pujols (3 wins)	6.91	3.	Greg Maddux* (4 wins)	4.92
4.	Ted Williams* (2 wins)	6.43	4.	Steve Carlton* (4 wins)	4.29
5.	Willie Mays* (2 wins)	5.94	5.	Pedro Martinez* (3 wins)	4.26
6.	Mickey Mantle* (3 wins)	5.79	6.	Tom Seaver* (3 wins)	3.85
7.	Hank Aaron* (1 win)	5.45	7.	Jim Palmer* (3 wins)	3.57
8.	Lou Gehrig* (2 wins)	5.44	8.	Roy Halladay (2 wins)	3.50
9.	Joe DiMaggio* (3 wins)	5.43	9.	Clayton Kershaw (3 wins)	3.34
10.	Alex Rodriguez (3 wins)	5.23

[Bostongambler]

Williams

[jjgold]

Bonds just had a unreal stroke
Toughest out there was

I bet he could still hit now

[Blackballer]

Mike Trout (currently one of the top 5 this year) and in the top 10 all-time in the future when he keeps playing like that.

[Bostongambler]

Mike Trout (currently one of the top 5 this year) and in the top 10 all-time in the future when he keeps playing like that.

Give me a W
Give me a H
Give me a A
Give me a T

What does it spell? WHAT!!!!!!

[trobin31]

Josh Gibson

[Akajason18]

whos the best hitter in the game today? Trout?

[Bostongambler]

Ron Kittle

[eidolon]

Look at how late he starts his swing at 8:40, yet still crushes the ball. The guys bat speed was ridiculous.

[stevenash]

Where is Lou Gherig?

Exactly, any top ten list that excludes Gehrig is just ignorant, and that's being kind.
He led the majors in RBI five times batting behind Ruth.
Lifetime .340 hitter.

Enough said

[Ra77er]

Where is Lou Gherig?

Mo I believe he has passed on and left a foundation behind in his honor.

[stevenash]

whos the best hitter in the game today? Trout?

Without question

[The Giant]

Best hitter I ever saw.

It's a shame MLB colluded in 2008 to get him out of baseball. He was still better than 95% of hitters.

[pronk]

"Charlie Hustle" aka Pete Rose was the best.

[Ra77er]

trout that one is closed, he wins games today by himself.

Historically Barry is pretty damn good, that swing is also pretty damn good regardless of PEDS.

[Ghenghis Kahn]

[pavyracer]

Chipper Jones. He could hit from both sides of plate. Barry Bonds was not amphibious.