You know you made a bad play when...

[darkghost]

you play the under on a game and each team scores more than the game total!!!! ala Ball State(60) v W. Michigan(57)

I was smart enough to play the 1st half, 2nd half & total game under.... dohhh!!!

[Mudcat]

I thought you might say:

You know you made a bad play when you've bet the UNDER and the game surpasses the total by the 2-minute warning - of the first half.

I've had a few games like that this year.