Eli Manning Is Finished

[jjgold]

How did he decline so fast?

He is not even a top 15 qb now

[Sam Odom]

Drugs... ?

[tto827]

His team sucks, no point in working his ass off this season.

Just like the Texans, this year a fluke, they'll be at least 9-7 and competitive next year

[sneakerhead]

Was he ever on top goldie?

[BennyBigNuts]

Eli has and always will be the most overrated QB of all-time.
It's not even a debate.
Old news.
Pick machine his whole career.
Monster Giant defenses made him look 10 times better than he ever was.

[BetsandBeer]

hes great in the 4th qtr of any superbowl. but other than that he sucks balls

[nvrlose37]

Clutch in the playoffs with a great defense at his disposal. He is never going to make waves statistically.

[a4u2fear]

Two Super Bowls. Hmmmm

[C-Gold]

Worst O-Line in the league and no running game against one of the best secondaries of the last 10 years. Of course he was going to throw picks today. Should have read my write up.

[MoneyzForSportz]

Eli has always been a turnover machine but because of his performances in the playoffs he is overrated. Combine that with the fact that the Giants have no running game and you get what you have seen all season.

[jjgold]

Manning is reason Giants are bad

He blew almost every game with costly int

[StackinGreen]

Eli has always been a turnover machine but because of his performances in the playoffs he is overrated. Combine that with the fact that the Giants have no running game and you get what you have seen all season.

INdeed.

[InTheDrink]

lol i thought this was one of the other 3 threads jjer started about eli

[ThaTopMoron]

How did he decline so fast?

He is not even a top 15 qb now

he isn't finished, he just isn't elite enough to carry a subpar team w/injuries & less talent to the playoffs like Brady, Peyton and Rodgers

Peyton dragged a couple teams in his Colt years to the playoffs. Even in his last year in 2010 when they had a million injuries.

[RonPaul2008]

How did he decline so fast?

He is not even a top 15 qb now

He was never very good.

[NYSportsGuy210]

How did he decline so fast?

He is not even a top 15 qb now

Holy overreaction thread to gain views Batman!

[t-wizzle]

He was never good to begin with.

[SteveRyan]

Let's see if Eli can throw yet a 5th interception in this game.

[easyliving]

Let's see if Eli can throw yet a 5th interception in this game.

you know it

[SteveRyan]

Let's see if Eli can throw yet a 5th interception in this game.

Yep! When is it appropriate to bench a 2 Superbowl QB?

[BennyBigNuts]

Yep! When is it appropriate to bench a 2 Superbowl QB?

10 games ago.

[jjgold]

5 interceptions today
He is washed up

Won superbowls on miracle plays

[TheMLBKing]

Eli has and always will be the most overrated QB of all-time.
It's not even a debate.
Old news.
Pick machine his whole career.
Monster Giant defenses made him look 10 times better than he ever was.

says the dumbass knicks fan.

[wagerjunkie]

http://forum.sbrforum.com/players-talk/2735604-seattle-cbs-absolutely-schooling-eli-giants-wrs-one-one-coverage.html

quit riding my jock jjer

[DALLASROB]

Eli has and always will be the most overrated QB of all-time.
It's not even a debate.
Old news.
Pick machine his whole career.
Monster Giant defenses made him look 10 times better than he ever was.

ding ding ding

[Celtics08]

Eli MUGnning

[StackinGreen]

5 interceptions today
He is washed up

Won superbowls on miracle plays

JJ, just to be fair (and you aren't wrong about lucky plays), Eli doesn't have a very good team surrounding and this D is absolutely FEROCIOUS

The real question isn't how bad is Eli, it's

Why didn't JJGold have a lot on Seattle like the Stacker?

[slacker00]

10 games ago.

You prefer Curtis Painter over Eli Manning?

[darkhat]

Won superbowls on miracle plays

I laugh every time some idiot giant's fan tries to claim eli is better than brady based off two lucky superbowls

eli manning has always been overrated.

[Capper1124]

He may have been finished 5 weeks ago. LOL

[The Giant]

The Giants started bad, and Eli has taken the rest of the year off.

He'll rebound next year.

[smitch124]

Every time anyone criticizes Eli I hear he won 2 Super Bowl MVPs. Right, I hear that, a great accomplishment. How long does that give you a pass though? Can you just suck for years and get a pass because of that? He has been awful for awhile now. At some point his play has to be looked at objectively, doesn't it?

[rcene]

Giants can't run the ball. Has had a huge effect on Manning. Overall they are a team in a major decline.

[rcene]

Coughlin sucks also.

[JACK MATZ]

Leave Eli alone!!!