Only the superior Manning will be in the picture now............

[tullamore]

I totally agree. He's also nothing without Brandon Jacobs. If teams force Eli Manning to beat them with his arm, he can't do it.

he is not accurate enough to win games on his own

[The Seer]

38.3 rating, he blew

NY Giants Comp Att Yds Pct Y/A Sack YdsL TD Int Rating
E. Manning 12 25 150 48.0 6.0 0 0 0 2 33.8

[The Seer]

Eli threw so many hail mary's last year that were caught by Plexico and the miracle catch in superbowl, he is ok but no where near a great QB

Warner is 50x better

agree again gold

[The_Kid]

Nice avatar, Seer

Today, the Eagles exposed Eli Manning for what he really is. He can't stand pressure and he can't make throws. Without Plax, he looks lost out there because his favorite receiver isn't there to bail him out every time. Please don't give me the excuse that the wind was a factor because McNabb looked fine once he got settled in. If you make the Giants play catchup, they can't. Eli Manning is NOT THAT GOOD and he shouldn't even be compared to Peyton.

[Tsoprano]

Eli was shit this game.

Just terrible.