Pennington Or Manning?? Who Wins MVP??

[jjgold]

I say Chad

Taking a 1-15 team to win division

[rm18]

manning

[element1286]

Manning.

[RogueScholar]

I'd like to see Kurt Warner get it, there's a success story that we can all appreciate. From being cut by the Packers in training camp to working night shift restocking grocery store shelves, to the Arena League, then on to Super Bowl rings. He's the heart of the Cardinals, and even though they play in the most dismal NFL division, he's kept them on track for their first winning season during my lifetime.

[jjgold]

If Warner did not have those two bad games at end of year he might of won it

[Panic]

Matt Ryan.

[yisman]

definitely not Pennington. Warner doesn't deserve it either.

[SBR Lou]

Manning takes it.

[konck]

Can you guys get real go look at penistons numbers he is and always will be a cock

[WileOut]

Total homer post by hank, its matt ryan by a mile

[Bread]

I hate to say it, but probably bighead Manning.

[WileOut]

do.not.want.

[HAPPY BOY]

chad think he gets the nod over Manning. (total homer post by H B) but I'm right!

[onthewhat]

Michael Turner would be ahead of Matt Ryan

[Bread]

Do not want either.

[WileOut]

on the what you have not been watching falcons games this year. matt ryan is the clutchest rookie i've ever seen play. he willed the team to at least 5 wins this year.

And another he threaded the needle from 60 yards out to White who dropped the ball which would have put them at 12 wins.

[BeatTheJerk]

Well I don't how the hell you can win an NFL MVP award and ultimately not get voted to the Pro Bowl. So no for Chad Pennington and yes for I d/k ..................

[hoopster42]

on the what you have not been watching falcons games this year. matt ryan is the clutchest rookie i've ever seen play. he willed the team to at least 5 wins this year.

clutchest rookie and mvp can be mutually exclusive

i believe its between pennington & ryan, but just becoz ryan is a rookie it doesnt mean he should be given more consideration than pennington, its like saying a freshman should win the heisman because, 'wow, look what he's doing as a freshman'! a freshman has never won the heisman, not even once, and only 2 sophs in history have, that would be tebow and bradford

i say pennington & ryan should be the top 2 and you cant really argue either way. shit, joe flacco is a rookie and led a 5-11 team from last yr to the playoffs this season

[hoopster42]

on the what you have not been watching falcons games this year. matt ryan is the clutchest rookie i've ever seen play. he willed the team to at least 5 wins this year.

And another he threaded the needle from 60 yards out to White who dropped the ball which would have put them at 12 wins.

12 wins? they probably won a few they shouldve lost as well. shoulda coulda woulda. they are 11-5 period end of fukken story. every team who makes the playoffs has a few more bounces go their way than go against them

homer alert here with you, dude

[WileOut]

Matt Ryan did it in a tougher conference against better defenses.

No homer hoopster only thinking about making the trip west to arizona. Only been a fan since Bartkowski.