If you had to rank the 5 active Superbowl winning QBs...

[SportsPedagogy]

If you were drafting a team for one season, and you could pick a Superbowl winning QB for that season, what would your draft board look like. I think mine is about standard, but I am interested in other peoples.

1. Brady
2. Peyton Manning
3. Aaron Rodgers
4.Drew Brees
5. Ben Rothilsburger
6. Eli Manning

[darkhat]

Brady
Peyton/Brees
Eli
Ben

[str]

Because he reinvented the position, IMO:

P. Manning
Brady
Eli/Brees
Roth.

[Saunders FTW]

Brady
Rodgers
P. Manning
Roth
Batch

[ericthegangster]

Aaron Rodgers is no longer an active super bowl winning QB? Or is he just obviously so much better than all of the others that you didn't include him?

[convick]

Aaron Rodgers is no longer an active super bowl winning QB? Or is he just obviously so much better than all of the others that you didn't include him?

Brady
Rodgers
P. Manning
E. Manning

[CDMKMP]

Yeah, lack of Rodgers kills credibility here. I'd take him over Big Ben or Brees right now.

[SportsPedagogy]

Aaron Rodgers is no longer an active super bowl winning QB? Or is he just obviously so much better than all of the others that you didn't include him?

Whoops ....

[easyliving]

brady
peyton
rodgers
eli
Brees

maybe rodgers' and peyton's places could be swapped but thats about it.

[SportsPedagogy]

brady
peyton
rodgers
eli
Brees

maybe rodgers' and peyton's places could be swapped but thats about it.

I can not justify Eli or Ben over Brees.

[stevenash]

Ben's performances in SB's have hardly been stellar.

Give me Peyton, then Brady or Eli or Rodgers.

[SportsPedagogy]

Ben's performances in SB's have hardly been stellar.

Give me Peyton, then Brady or Eli or Rodgers.

I take it back, i could see Eli over Ben... but I think there is a large gap separating Peyton, Brees, Brady and Rodgers fron Eli and Ben

[stevenash]

I take it back, i could see Eli over Ben... but I think there is a large gap separating Peyton, Brees, Brady and Rodgers fron Eli and Ben

I'm a NYG homer, I get that, but whenever Eli gets to the big one, he just seems to win it.

[meader99]

If it's for one season, I want Rodgers. If it's for one game, such as the Super Bowl, gimme Eli.

[BuddyBear]

1. Rodgers
2. Other 5

[Andy117]

Peyton
Brady
Rodgers
Brees
Eli
Ben

[Ambition]

Brady
Rodgers
Eli
Peyton
Big Ben

The size of Brees really annoys me.

[lakerboy]

Rodgers is the best qb in the game easily.

[pavyracer]

Rodgers is the best qb in the game easily.

And that's why the Packers will miss the playoffs this year.

[Vesuvius]

Brady
Rodgers
Peyton
Eli
Ben
Brees

[Ambition]

And that's why the Packers will miss the playoffs this year.

Since when are the Packers missing the playoffs? They're going to win the division.

[pavyracer]

Since when are the Packers missing the playoffs? They're going to win the division.

It was predicted here:

http://forum.sbrforum.com/players-talk/1847586-green-bay-packers-will-not-make-playoffs-year.html#post15659990

[B1GER1C828]

Ben's performances in SB's have hardly been stellar.

Give me Peyton, then Brady or Eli or Rodgers.

and hardly stellar you mean his 1st 1 he did jack shit? possibly biggest fluke win for a qb ever. like god was that performance pathetic or what?9-23 or somethng? 150 yars or bs? penetrate big ben. and peyton over brady? oh fuk off pal.