who ya got ? -
who ya got ? -
manning brady
rodgers questionable
thats itComment -
Two...Manning, BradyComment -
not even rodgers yet just manning and brady.Comment -
In order
Blaine Gabbert
Brady Quinn
Michael VickComment -
Three. Manning, Brady, Brees.Comment -
How many Bottom Ten Failures are QB'ing today?
Rivers,Romo...
Feel free to add.Comment -
where would you guys put Big ben? cant stand the guy but all he does is win games. id say top 10-15 for sureComment -
Gabbert
Brady Quinn
Eli Manning
Mike VickComment -
1 montana
2 brady
3 unitas
4 manning
5 elway
6 favre
7 marino
8 young
9 and 10 take your pick baugh, graham aikman, bradshaw, staubach, starr, brees, kaepernickComment -
Both Mannings, Brady, Brees, Rodgers, and Big Ben. Most likely to make this list later without question, Luck.Comment -
7 of the top 10 qb's of all time are playing right now?Originally posted by seaborneq
Comment -
Easy answer: Manning and BradyComment -
Manning, Brady... Brees, and perhaps Rodgers.Comment -
Marino #7????Originally posted by InTheDrink
Comment -
I agree with the consensus /. Brady , manningComment -
you might be able to get him to 5 but i dont think soOriginally posted by JeffieMarino #7????
if you say he's top 4 then you have no argumentComment -
I do not think Big Ben is top 10, nor will he be. He may make HoF cause of the Superbowls, but he was lucky to be drafted to an already good team. That defense carried them most of the way. His first Super Bowl he set the record for worst QB rating by a Super Bowl winning QB.Comment -
I hope all the mannings here are Eli.... because ELI> Brady and Brady>PeytonComment -
Big Ben has won 2 Superbowls
Comment -
the steelers have won 2 super bowls with big ben playing qbOriginally posted by helsBig Ben has won 2 Superbowls
Comment -
How is Eli better then Brady ?Originally posted by wantitall4moi
Please do not use the head to head argument, they were facing two different defenses. You can not measure by that. If that was the case, then Rex Grossman would own Eli.Comment -
Trent Dilfer won a Super Bowl.Originally posted by helsBig Ben has won 2 SuperbowlsComment -
Manning, BradyComment -
Has to be Manning and Brady. Brees is right on the outskirts. I like Brees because he's phenomenal and he's the heart and soul of his team. Can't say that about many other quarterbacks these days.Comment -
Two
ARod nowhere near top 10 all time yet. When he is done maybe
Brees not even in the discussionComment -
manning and brady and thats it.
rodgers still needs to accomplish a whole lot more.
brees not even in the discussion
eli might be there if he continues at this rate and maybe wins another ring but he still has alot of years ahead of him.Comment -
yea because rex grossman beat Eli Manning in a Superbowl.Originally posted by SportsPedagogyComment -
Manning, Brady, Breeze, Rodgers, i want to add Big Ben but i don't think he'll be considered top 10 all time when its all said and done.Comment -
Obviously not current but funny how Doug Flutie never makes any top QB lists. Guy did it everywhere and he was 4 feet tall, if he was even 6 feet tall he would have probably been the best ever.Comment -
Two QB's, head to head, in any game, is not a measuring stick for QB's. They have different people around them, and they play different defenses. The Giants won their Superbowl thanks to their defense. The Patriots had a horrible defense last year.Originally posted by wantitall4moiComment -
Kid really mention kaepernack? Unreal
Brady
Manning
End of threadComment
