Who would you take... Oden or Rose?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • 5 star bomb
    SBR Hall of Famer
    • 10-12-07
    • 5370

    #1
    Who would you take... Oden or Rose?
    If you could start a franchise with one of these players who would you take??
  • Chi_archie
    SBR Aristocracy
    • 07-22-08
    • 63172

    #2
    Rose....

    good big men are rare... but Oden hasn't proved much, and has too many Injury issues. Don't think we will see too many healthy years from him.
    Comment
    • hoopster42
      Restricted User
      • 02-12-08
      • 6099

      #3
      oden, have to take a big man, tougher to find, even with the injury issues the upside is too high, too much +EV with oden
      Comment
      • Chi_archie
        SBR Aristocracy
        • 07-22-08
        • 63172

        #4
        that being said... I bet Rose wouldn't mind get picked by ANYONE else right now.

        felt bad for him last night, when I watched snippets of the bulls-blazers game... how many of the bulls regulars would see anything more then garbage time on a good NBA franchise?


        Who was the last bull all-star?
        Comment
        • Chi_archie
          SBR Aristocracy
          • 07-22-08
          • 63172

          #5
          give me a game-changing point gaurd first.... don't need a great big man to win anymore IMO ... I'll take a Chris Paul, or Steve Nash before I look at the 5
          Comment
          • Kingctb27
            SBR MVP
            • 07-16-08
            • 2258

            #6
            Oden for me. Defense wins championships. Ask Timmy.
            Comment
            • fiveteamer
              SBR Posting Legend
              • 04-14-08
              • 10805

              #7
              Oden?

              Guy has glass knees.

              Why would you pick him.
              Comment
              • hoopster42
                Restricted User
                • 02-12-08
                • 6099

                #8
                consider this:

                shaq won championships with kobe and one with wade, but kobe and wade never won without shaq

                duncan won a championship before parker and ginobli were on the spurs (99), and has won 3 with them

                great big men are much harder to find and more instrumental to success than great little men
                Comment
                • hoopster42
                  Restricted User
                  • 02-12-08
                  • 6099

                  #9
                  and please dont bring up the bulls with jordan and pippen who had no big men

                  jordan is a one in a billion
                  Comment
                  • fiveteamer
                    SBR Posting Legend
                    • 04-14-08
                    • 10805

                    #10
                    you are forgetting that Oden has the same disease that Andre the giant has, he wont make it to 30, guy will fall apart.
                    Comment
                    • Quebb Diesel
                      SBR MVP
                      • 01-26-08
                      • 3045

                      #11
                      Originally posted by fiveteamer
                      you are forgetting that Oden has the same disease that Andre the giant has, he wont make it to 30, guy will fall apart.
                      oden had microfracture surgery...andre died from a pituitary tumor he never treated throughout his life...any claims that oden has any pituitary diseases are speculation
                      Comment
                      • WileOut
                        SBR MVP
                        • 02-04-07
                        • 3844

                        #12
                        Originally posted by Chi_archie
                        that being said... I bet Rose wouldn't mind get picked by ANYONE else right now.

                        felt bad for him last night, when I watched snippets of the bulls-blazers game... how many of the bulls regulars would see anything more then garbage time on a good NBA franchise?


                        Who was the last bull all-star?
                        Whats hard for me to understand is that this same Bulls team minus Ben Wallace is the Bulls team that was supposed to take over the east after they beat defending champions Miami in the playoffs and then lost to Detroit I think. Everyone said they were the team to beat in the east for the next year. I just can't believe they collapsed like they did. I guess Ben Wallace makes more of a difference than people think.

                        Rose is not a real point guard. Don't get me wrong, he is maybe the most athletic guy I've ever seen, but he will never be a Chris Paul or Deron Williams. He just doesn't have the ability to get others involved and run a team like those guys do.

                        And I'm not sure about Oden. I don't know if he is going to ever be much of an offensive threat. He has a very long way to go. Right now he can get shut down by a good post defender.
                        Comment
                        • WileOut
                          SBR MVP
                          • 02-04-07
                          • 3844

                          #13
                          Originally posted by hoopster42
                          consider this:

                          shaq won championships with kobe and one with wade, but kobe and wade never won without shaq

                          duncan won a championship before parker and ginobli were on the spurs (99), and has won 3 with them

                          great big men are much harder to find and more instrumental to success than great little men
                          Kobe is about to win like 5 in a row without shaq.
                          Comment
                          • etothep
                            SBR MVP
                            • 09-14-07
                            • 1299

                            #14
                            Is there a 3rd option?
                            Comment
                            • bigboydan
                              SBR Aristocracy
                              • 08-10-05
                              • 55420

                              #15
                              How can't anyone not pick Oden is beyond me. So the guy had some injuries early in his career, big deal. He will be a HOF'er after it all said and done.
                              Comment
                              • etothep
                                SBR MVP
                                • 09-14-07
                                • 1299

                                #16
                                Originally posted by bigboydan
                                How can't anyone not pick Oden is beyond me. So the guy had some injuries early in his career, big deal. He will be a HOF'er after it all said and done.
                                Who doesn't love the Bowie Argument?
                                Comment
                                • Kingctb27
                                  SBR MVP
                                  • 07-16-08
                                  • 2258

                                  #17
                                  Originally posted by WileOut
                                  Kobe is about to win like 5 in a row without shaq.
                                  Yeah, with two big guys. lol.
                                  Comment
                                  • hoopster42
                                    Restricted User
                                    • 02-12-08
                                    • 6099

                                    #18
                                    Originally posted by WileOut
                                    Kobe is about to win like 5 in a row without shaq.
                                    first he needs to win one without shaq, bro.

                                    he disappeared in the finals, never taking over games when they needed him, and his frontline got dominated by the celtics

                                    we'll see if bynum makes the difference this yr

                                    first win one, then talk about two

                                    baby steps buddy, baby steps

                                    "KOBE HOW MY ASS TASTE?"

                                    - Shaq at a nyc club last june

                                    kobe without shaq = ZERO titles

                                    shaq without kobe = ONE

                                    winner, shaq
                                    Comment
                                    • PedroG
                                      SBR Hustler
                                      • 11-19-08
                                      • 96

                                      #19
                                      Odens legs are made of Balsa wood, however I bet he has a cock made of steel.
                                      Comment
                                      • Chi_archie
                                        SBR Aristocracy
                                        • 07-22-08
                                        • 63172

                                        #20
                                        nice first post Pedro!!
                                        Comment
                                        Search
                                        Collapse
                                        SBR Contests
                                        Collapse
                                        Top-Rated US Sportsbooks
                                        Collapse
                                        Working...