IF Verlander Wins Cy Young this year is he a shoe in for the HOF?

[Chi_archie]

what if he gets 2nd in Cy Young this year, Detroit wins the WS,and then gets another no-hitter in 2013 then retires from a freak injury?

how much more work does he need in your mind to convince you to vote for him if you had a vote?

[CanuckG]

Wont win Cy this year most likely World Series and yes lock for HOF

[face]

you have to be good for 10 years to get into hall of fame. dwight gooden was amazing for 5 years and is not in.

[CanuckG]

dwight gooden was a fukk up irl bias from voters

[paco]

He will get in if he stopped playing tomorrow.

[TxAaron]

He will get in if he stopped playing tomorrow.

very retarded statement...JV isn't even top 200 in all time strikeouts. Only like 120 wins. He needs a lot more innings to be considered.

[Chi_archie]

you have to be good for 10 years to get into hall of fame. dwight gooden was amazing for 5 years and is not in.

Koufax was only really good for 6 years. that was kind of the premise of my idea for the thread.

has any guy that threw 3 no hitters not gotten into the hall?

Dwight was only great for 2-3 years

[Chi_archie]

Has a .62 WHIP .74 era and hitters have a combined .122 avg against him in 24 innings this post season