Is A-Rod The Most Overrated Bigtime Athlete Of All-Time?

[Sunde91]

Buried. Everyone thinks he sucks and he's proven it outside 09. Overpaid not overrated

[milwaukee mike]

He's just become a very ordinary player the last few seasons. But let's face it, prior to that you just can't argue with his numbers, and while his postseason numbers are not as good as regular season, he still had some really good postseasons too.

Come on man

Just struck out again when a sacrifice wins the series

1-18 with runners in scoring position in the postseason is beyond pathetic

[PhillyFlyers]

A-Rod came through again for the Yankees last night didn't he?



This guy is fukkin horrible.

Drop his ass to 8th in the batting order, DH Ibanez or else lose the series tonight.

The guy is done.

[WvGambler]

Mike Vick

[PhillyFlyers]

Mike Vick

No way. Not even close.

A-Rod was at one point, being championed as one of the greatest baseball players ever. No one ever said Michael Vick was one of the greatest QBs ever.

Vick not close to A-Rod as far as being bigtime.

[seaborneq]

Pat ewing should be on this mount rushmore too. Never played best when it mattered most.

[Big Bear]

hmm i would say that would be Albert Pujols