Who's the NL MVP?

[InTheDrink]

Pretty strong case for Buster Posey...

http://www.mercurynews.com/giants/ci_21700567/buster-posey-san-francisco-giants-catcher-was-epitome

He'll at least win comeback poty

guy is like the new jeter...class act who gets respect whether you like the giants or not

[Deuce]

Posey
Braun

Posey wins, team made playoffs. Case closed.

[milwaukee mike]

Posey
Braun

Posey wins, team made playoffs. Case closed.

the case is most certainly not closed just because one team made the playoffs

look at the giants pitching staff vs the brewers pitching staff

who would you have rather had on your team in 2012? braun or posey? posey much better average, braun much better power #s

[Bostongambler]

Posey

[Deuce]

the case is most certainly not closed just because one team made the playoffs

look at the giants pitching staff vs the brewers pitching staff

who would you have rather had on your team in 2012? braun or posey? posey much better average, braun much better power #s

Posey

He is a catcher. Show me another behind the plate with those numbers.

[delpiero7]

Has to be Posey. Apart from his all round game, the guy just seems to be a total class act.

Despite the power numbers, I can't imagine it going to Braun again after the non-suspension at the start of the season.

[2daBank]

yadi has best war in baseball does he not....ppl nevr give yadi respect he deserves, best defensive cather in baseball and had great offensive year, him and posey both the most important guys on their team tho so hard to argue either..

[jjgold]

In reality Braun deserves it but he is blackballed

[InTheDrink]

yadi has best war in baseball does he not....ppl nevr give yadi respect he deserves, best defensive cather in baseball and had great offensive year, him and posey both the most important guys on their team tho so hard to argue either..

good point about him not getting respect but a catcher's defense is damn near impossible to rate because of how they work with the staff....yadi is better than buster no doubt but not as much as the numbers show IMO....theres no disputing that buster is tremendously better at the plate

[2daBank]

good point about him not getting respect but a catcher's defense is damn near impossible to rate because of how they work with the staff....yadi is better than buster no doubt but not as much as the numbers show IMO....theres no disputing that buster is tremendously better at the plate

honestly dont know either numbers really, havnt followed a ton the last month,,i know yadi had a very good offensive yr and the guy gets hits when they count,,,i know both teams be screwed w/o either one of them so i wouldnt bitch either way but as a cards homer of coarse id luv to see yadi at least finish high in the voting..

[Br0nxer]

Posey

Braun is a cheater. No way he wins. Blackballed as Gold said

[meader99]

Posey

Braun is a cheater. No way he wins. Blackballed as Gold said

Time to move on from the cheater BS. Not only did he win his appeal, he put up better numbers this year under a lot more pressure. Speaks more volume then the peanut gallery calling him a cheater.

[gummo]

Braun should win but Posey will.

[daneblazer]

Yadier Molina should get votes

[rdegk15]

Ryan Braun. There shouldn't even be a discussion about it.

[lakerboy]

I say johhny cueto

[ronzer]

Braun....