All Time NFL QB Ratings Listings

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • no gnu taxes
    SBR Wise Guy
    • 08-18-11
    • 805

    #1
    All Time NFL QB Ratings Listings


    I just posted this because of discussions on other threads about rating QBs based on passing ratings.

    The list is a bit interesting, and heavily weighted in favor of QBS of the last 10 years or so.

    Some interesting notes:

    No. 1 all time -- Aaron Rodgers. No big surprise

    No.2 all time -- Tony Romo. Never would have guessed that considering what a LOSER he is.

    Tied for No. 9 with Joe Montana -- Matt Schaub. Matt who? Does he clean the gutters at Texan's stadium or something like that?

    No. 18 -- Carson Palmer --- Hasn't this guy demonstrated what a mediocre talent he is? Can't believe he still plays.

    No. 42 -- Ken Anderson. One of the best field generals ever and comes limping in at No. 42?

    No. 71 -- Johnny Unitas. Need I say more?

    No. 187 -- Joe Namath. Ok, about where this overrated show horse deserves to be.

    No. 216 Joe Kapp and No. 234 Bobby Douglass. No comment on their passing abilities, but you wouldn't want to mess with either of these two QBs in a dark alley. They would spit at anyone suggesting "keep the QBs safe rules" when they were playing.


    Many more things I could say, but you can form your own opinion.
  • CanuckG
    SBR Posting Legend
    • 12-23-10
    • 21978

    #2
    Comment
    • no gnu taxes
      SBR Wise Guy
      • 08-18-11
      • 805

      #3
      wow. One I didn't mention was Roman Gabriel. An outstanding QB and MVP. No. 115.
      Comment
      • ChalkyDog
        SBR Hall of Famer
        • 10-02-11
        • 9598

        #4
        Any list that has a Packer at number 1, is a flawed list.

        Comment
        • dmtrader
          SBR MVP
          • 09-26-09
          • 1320

          #5
          The obvious lesson to take from this is that QB rating is not a certain predictor of success (in a W/L sense). Some NFL legends are way down the list. And Tony Romo (who actually is a very good QB) and Phillip Rivers are ranked very high, despite never winning Super Bowls like QBs ranked near them (like Peyton, Tom Brady, Steve Young, etc.)

          One QB from the old era (1940's-1950's) who is ranked very high is Otto Graham (#16). I don't think any of us on the board realize just how dominant he was with the Browns, winning championship after championship and setting passing records that would stand for years.

          My father used to recollect the old classic games between the Lions and Browns,where Graham would put up incredible numbers in those championship games.
          Comment
          • Brock Landers
            SBR Aristocracy
            • 06-30-08
            • 45359

            #6
            stupidest list i have ever seen
            Comment
            • k13
              SBR Posting Legend
              • 07-16-10
              • 18104

              #7
              Once Romo and Rivers finish their careers they will be below Young, Brady, etc.
              Comment
              • Monitor-Tan
                SBR MVP
                • 02-20-11
                • 4460

                #8
                Ah yes the QB rating list where you can put up 150 QB rating in garbage time...
                Comment
                • no gnu taxes
                  SBR Wise Guy
                  • 08-18-11
                  • 805

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Brock Landers
                  stupidest list i have ever seen
                  Honestly, Mr. Brock, I've never seen you post any kind of thought you might have, other than some bizarre off the cuff prediction, whether it's your own or something you've seen referenced elsewhere. You call things stupid, but what is stupid according to you?

                  How stupid is this? LSU -20. Go for it gambler. LSU doesn't cover? I don't post here again for 6 months.
                  Comment
                  • RawBillyIce
                    SBR MVP
                    • 02-08-12
                    • 2036

                    #10
                    Seems very odd that all the current QB's are at top of list.
                    Comment
                    • no gnu taxes
                      SBR Wise Guy
                      • 08-18-11
                      • 805

                      #11
                      Originally posted by RawBillyIce
                      Seems very odd that all the current QB's are at top of list.
                      I think I mentioned it in the first paragragh.

                      It would take another thread to try and explain it to you if you don't already know why.
                      Comment
                      • crustyme
                        SBR Posting Legend
                        • 09-29-10
                        • 16896

                        #12
                        Originally posted by no gnu taxes
                        Honestly, Mr. Brock, I've never seen you post any kind of thought you might have, other than some bizarre off the cuff prediction, whether it's your own or something you've seen referenced elsewhere. You call things stupid, but what is stupid according to you?

                        How stupid is this? LSU -20. Go for it gambler. LSU doesn't cover? I don't post here again for 6 months.
                        come on auburn.
                        Comment
                        • CanuckG
                          SBR Posting Legend
                          • 12-23-10
                          • 21978

                          #13
                          Even if they don't cover he'll stay unfortunately....
                          Comment
                          • CanuckG
                            SBR Posting Legend
                            • 12-23-10
                            • 21978

                            #14
                            Originally posted by no gnu taxes
                            Honestly, Mr. Brock, I've never seen you post any kind of thought you might have, other than some bizarre off the cuff prediction, whether it's your own or something you've seen referenced elsewhere. You call things stupid, but what is stupid according to you?

                            How stupid is this? LSU -20. Go for it gambler. LSU doesn't cover? I don't post here again for 6 months.
                            Proven once again to be fukkin clueless about sports. Same with politics.

                            Cya kid.
                            Comment
                            • crustyme
                              SBR Posting Legend
                              • 09-29-10
                              • 16896

                              #15
                              gtfo.

                              Comment
                              • Blissit02
                                SBR Wise Guy
                                • 07-16-11
                                • 710

                                #16
                                Ryan Leaf didnt make the list?
                                Comment
                                • CanuckG
                                  SBR Posting Legend
                                  • 12-23-10
                                  • 21978

                                  #17
                                  Comment
                                  • PAULYPOKER
                                    BARRELED IN @ SBR!
                                    • 12-06-08
                                    • 36581

                                    #18
                                    Originally posted by no gnu taxes
                                    .

                                    The list is a bit interesting, and heavily weighted in favor of QBS of the last 10 years or so.


                                    Many more things I could say, but you can form your own opinion.
                                    The reason for so many QBs from the last 10 years or so ranking the highest is the NFL has completely changed the rules to cater to the modern QB/passing game,making Qb ratings considerably unjust to great QBs of the past..............

                                    Exciting entertainment is the new NFL and the passing game is the trump...............
                                    Comment
                                    • ThePancreas
                                      SBR Rookie
                                      • 09-24-12
                                      • 33

                                      #19
                                      Romo #2 is just insane. That is one of those goofy stats that just doesn't add up.
                                      Comment
                                      • crustyme
                                        SBR Posting Legend
                                        • 09-29-10
                                        • 16896

                                        #20
                                        Comment
                                        • KKoz9
                                          SBR MVP
                                          • 09-07-06
                                          • 1982

                                          #21
                                          The NFL passer rating is a statistic developed to evaluate a QBs play INDEPENDENT of their team's success, or lack thereof, in the win column.

                                          Or for you Romo haters, how many field goal snaps they drop, lol.
                                          Comment
                                          • rm18
                                            SBR Posting Legend
                                            • 09-20-05
                                            • 22291

                                            #22
                                            Robert Griffin would be #1 all time if he had enough attempts to qualify
                                            Comment
                                            • Avenger
                                              SBR MVP
                                              • 03-15-11
                                              • 2119

                                              #23
                                              Uh.... Peyton Manning?

                                              How can a all-time QB thread be made without mentioning him?
                                              Comment
                                              • The Seer
                                                SBR Posting Legend
                                                • 10-29-07
                                                • 10641

                                                #24
                                                Originally posted by PAULYPOKER
                                                The reason for so many QBs from the last 10 years or so ranking the highest is the NFL has completely changed the rules to cater to the modern QB/passing game,making Qb ratings considerably unjust to great QBs of the past..............

                                                Exciting entertainment is the new NFL and the passing game is the trump...............
                                                This is correct. The illegal contact and pass interference changes have drastically changed the game in the favor of modern quarterback..
                                                Comment
                                                • CanuckG
                                                  SBR Posting Legend
                                                  • 12-23-10
                                                  • 21978

                                                  #25
                                                  Originally posted by no gnu taxes
                                                  Honestly, Mr. Brock, I've never seen you post any kind of thought you might have, other than some bizarre off the cuff prediction, whether it's your own or something you've seen referenced elsewhere. You call things stupid, but what is stupid according to you?

                                                  How stupid is this? LSU -20. Go for it gambler. LSU doesn't cover? I don't post here again for 6 months.
                                                  Nice lie.
                                                  Comment
                                                  • CanuckG
                                                    SBR Posting Legend
                                                    • 12-23-10
                                                    • 21978

                                                    #26
                                                    Comment
                                                    • RonPaul2008
                                                      SBR Hall of Famer
                                                      • 06-08-07
                                                      • 6741

                                                      #27
                                                      Pretty sure the top for a single season is Steve Young.
                                                      Comment
                                                      • meader99
                                                        SBR MVP
                                                        • 10-30-10
                                                        • 4223

                                                        #28
                                                        Originally posted by RonPaul2008
                                                        Pretty sure the top for a single season is Steve Young.
                                                        Rodgers shattered that last year.
                                                        Comment
                                                        Search
                                                        Collapse
                                                        SBR Contests
                                                        Collapse
                                                        Top-Rated US Sportsbooks
                                                        Collapse
                                                        Working...