Aaron Rodgers is definitely in Brady/Manning/Brees class

[Power Play]

Absolutely incredible passer. Probably has the strongest arm out of the elite quarterbacks too.

[nj1035]

Not until he wins a SB.

[xX Das Boot Xx]

Not until he wins a SB.

it would be a bummer if he had to ranked near dan marino his whole life...superbowl wins are team efforts great qbs cannot do it alone although some have been an exception

Rodgers is so smooth

Under pressure a nice little spin to get away and throws a bullet to his receiver. Fukkin smooth and he'll be going back home and bang Erin Andrews while smoking a fat cuban. Livin the dream Packers +2.5

[Ace_of_Spades]

Don't jinx the Pack.

[IEDodgerFan]

Theres no jinxing the pack...Rodgers is GREAT under pressure, as he's proven so far...35-14

[CanuckG]

hes the real deal

[CanuckG]

holy shit another one he just gets away from so fukkin good

[beerman2619]

Wish i would of had him on my Fantasy team

[iifold]

Rodgers Passes Up Peyton, Is Now a in Top 3 alongside Brady, Big Ben....

1. Brady
1a. Ben
3. Rodgers
4. P.Manning
5. Brees

Don't tell me Manning runs the offense, him and his brother cant even throw spirals..

[yurnero]

LOL peyton is going to wreck shop next year, you just wait

[raiders510]

that list is 100% accurate, but to me the only 2 that matter are 1 and 1a

[Stevedore]

You Think Rodgers Is Good?

On the road in a dome and he destroys the Falcons and their #1 seed. 31-36 for 366 and 3 td's. Sick absolutely sick..yeah Matt Ryan is better. LMAO!!

[stefan084]

ben shouldn't be anywhere near the top 5

[GunShard]

Top 5 Elite Quarterbacks:

1. Tom Brady
2. P. Manning
3. Aaron Rodgers
4. Philip Rivers
5. Drew Brees

Leadership is a major factor. That's how I view this list.

There I fixed the list adding in the interception and TD factors for this season.

[Monte]

Dude Rivers is a major fail on this list, and so is Manning over Brady

[todd24kb]

Dude Rivers is a major fail on this list, and so is Manning over Brady

[mighty maron]

Rodgers is not top 5 til he wins a super bowl.

[Nomocino]

TOOL ........................... CLASS ACT


He may never break Favres records, but his teammates love him and he does not make the same idiotic mistakes late in games.

[Nomocino]

Weather could be a big factor, it suppose to be bitter cold with 18mph winds. I still think Cutler makes more mistakes and Rodgers will throw short slants nickle and dime down the field

[Power Play]

If he wins today I don't think there's any question of this.