Brady throws for 147 yards and the Pats score 31! I'm a Colts fan and I don't know that I would take Peyton over Brady but if PManning throws for 147...the Colts don't score over 10 points! If Brady has Vanderjagt as his kicker for many years like Manning...he'd be lucky to have 1 ring! I guess the credit goes to Belechik since he develops more talent than anyone around! Caldwell sucks and Dungy was overrated as well imo!
-
-
PManning numbers means nothing as his interception rate is very high.Comment -
Well put, Mr.H. Here, here!
Comment -
You're not getting my point? Manning has to throw 45+ times a game because the Colts can't do anything else? Brady has ALWAYS had a good to very good defense and running game behind him! I remember a game about 5 years ago where the Pats were beat up and Brady threw 4 picks against the Colts and lost!Comment -
Brady gave the Patriots a chance by not throwing interceptions and he made plays when he needed to. Nobody can throw for 400 yards every game. Manning would've been forcing things that aren't there and throwing interceptions. Brady knows what passes to throw and what not to throw, and when to throw them, that's what makes him better than Manning.Comment -
Uhhh his defense gave up how many points tonight? And how much TOP? I wouldn't call BenJarvis Green-Ellis a better RB than anyone the Colts have either.
Biggest difference between the Pats and Colts is that the Pats take advantage of opportunities, and the Colts can't seem to do that as wellComment -
Manning is pretty conservative when the situation calls for it.Comment -
Do I have to go back to Football 101 with some of you guys? Old School Rule #1:
3 things can happen on a forward pass.....2 of them are bad! The Colts are #32 in the league running the ball so PManning HAS to throw 40x a game....so bad things will happen...balls will be picked off! Brady had 147 yards tonite and they STILL put up 31 points! Manning CANNOT throw for 150 yards and expect the team to stay within 2 TDs!Comment -
If the situation called for it, Brady would've thrown for more yardage. I'm sure Brady would love to have the Colts defense. Perhaps if Manning threw the ball better it would open up the run a little more. You talk like Brady has Barry Sanders to hand the ball off to.Comment -
Thought we already went through this when Brady was easily (relatively) replaced by Cassel...Comment -
The Colts are also DEAD LAST in kickoff returns while the Pats have a fat bastard lineman running them back for 70 yards? Brady might be better...he definitely has a better arm...but he also has more plays made around him and doesn't have to carry the team like Manning!
To the other numnut poster on this thread.....BJ Green Ellis may/may not be better than Indy's RBs...but the Pats aren't 32nd in the NFL in rushing because their offensive line is pretty good! PManning has been in 3rd/9 all year it seems!Comment -
This is like deciding whether you'd like to be stranded on an Island with Jessica Alba or Megan Fox. Both Colt and Patriot fans should be very happy, and very thankful.Comment -
Yeah Manning sucks...you convinced me! Somehow the Colts just lucked into seven 12 win seasons in a row and another divisional title this year!Comment -
You're right...I think Colts fans give Brady alot more respect than the East coast aholes do Manning though! Its a good Rivalry and I've enjoyed the Colts 5-2 stretch against New England!Comment -
this thread is idiotic
is this supposed to prove manning is better than brady?
brady will prolly win the mvp this year, manning is having a bad year
how can people use the matt cassel argument?? the dude is about to lead his team to a division title
philip rivers is better than manning this yearComment -
Brady probably deserves the MVP this year too. I'm talking about their career here not just this year! My point is that Brady can throw for 147 and put up 31 points while Manning has ALWAYS had to carry the Colts and throw for 300 just to give them a shot!Comment -
Interesting thread. But I believe I have read this all before.Comment
