Is Aaron Rodgers considered an elite QB?

[dynamite140]

I have been hearing so much about him the last year or 2 since Favre left the packers. He certainly has great numbers but is he considered to be a top 5 QB? I been hearing so much about how a lot of people think Green Bay has a good shot at making the superbowl this year because of Rodgers.

I have

1. Peyton
2. Brady
3. Brees

I don't consider Ben an elite QB even though he won 2 Titles with the Steelers. His numbers don't look good and its always their defense that was their reason to win the championship. And Tony Romo, there is nothing good about this guy. All he does is choke in the playoffs and hasn't done anything meaningful. And Eli is okay but not elite.

But Rodgers is a bit tough to say. His passing stats has been great and he only started 2 seasons because of Favre but his numbers are very impressive.

Do you guys consider Aaron Rodgers to be a top tier QB in this league?

[Illusion]

If he wins a Super Bowl then yes the public will consider him elite. I actually think he is overated. Did you consider Brees elite before he won last year? Also, I completely agree with you on Big Ben

[dynamite140]

I considered Brees elite ever since he was on the Saints team. His numbers are incredible for passing yards ever since he arrived in New Orleans. His numbers when he was in San Diego didn't look superior whatsoever.

[actnatural]

i watch and made money off him over 4 yearz in preseason...and with a team like GB, yes he is!!!

[actnatural]

playoff vs Arz...that was all the defense fault!!!