Fantasy Question: Eli Manning or Matt Ryan?

[steve18]

If those were the two bets QBs left on the board in your Fantasy draft in the 6th round, who do you take? It's a keeper/dynasty league.

[plzkthx]

matt ryan without a doubt...

[itchypickle]

Ryan. Falcons are going to be pretty potent this year. You have to figure defenses will cheat up to try and stop a healthy Michael Turner before he gets going....so I can see some deep yards for the passing game. Not to mention...the NFC South isnt that stacked on D this year.

[onlooker]

Ryan, and if you can get White as well, that would be great.

[skilz4milz]

Go with Ryan. He is ranked higher in every FantasyFootBall publication that I've seen for the season. Plus I've had Eli for fantasy for several seasons in the past. He was ok at best in fantasy value and at times just down right killed me.

[officepoolguy]

Eli has not been a great fantasy player. Ryan is young, has a talented wr in White and a solid running game. They also play in a weaker division. I do think that the Giants will be better this year but Ryan is the pick.

[Facepunch]

Eli Manning has cost me so much money in the past couple of years, I would be disgusted to have him on my fantasy team. I think that ryan is the clear pick here.

I would take Sanchez over both of them though, If he is still on the board. I am shocked at how low he is ranked.

[DIRTYDIRTY]

this is really a no brainer eli plays outdoors and late in the season when u need him the most its snowing easy GO WITH THE DIRTYBIRD

[SpreadSniper]

Chris Johnson, Hines Ward, Brett Favre FOR Kevin Kolb, Larry Fitzgerald and Rashard Mendenhall

To pull the trigger or not to pull the trigger... If I don;t pull the trigger and Favre doesn't come back, this is going to be one big missed opportunity for me.

[Manaconda]

Chris Johnson, Hines Ward, Brett Favre FOR Kevin Kolb, Larry Fitzgerald and Rashard Mendenhall

To pull the trigger or not to pull the trigger... If I don;t pull the trigger and Favre doesn't come back, this is going to be one big missed opportunity for me.

i dont think id move chris johnson for anyone.. who else do you have at rb?
i dont think fitz has as big of a year with matt leinart throwing

[Jasonal_98]

Matt Ryan. This is going to be a huge year for him.

[ttwarrior1]

take kolb if there or c palmer later, if its 12 teams eli has been going in rd 9

[woody78]

Ryan.

[DIRTYDIRTY]

ryan trust me pro bowl year

[steve18]

Thanks to everyone who contributed to this thread. I ended up drafting Ryan in the 6th round. It's a keeper league. Thank you all for your help and suggestions. I really appreciated it.

[SpreadSniper]

i dont think id move chris johnson for anyone.. who else do you have at rb?
i dont think fitz has as big of a year with matt leinart throwing

It's a 16 team league with a $1000 buy-in. I got Javid Best and Marion Barber(flex) and a couple in reserve

[xxxvince]

this one is easy.. matt ryan

[TheJer]

I hate eli. Nice job going with Ryan.

[MikeZaW]

Matt Ryan for sure.

[alex81]

Don't trade chris johnson!!! Big big big mistake!!!

[ttwarrior1]

ryan in round six???? he is usually the 11th or 12th qb taken, u could of waited

[Betting Guru]

I'm rolling with Matt Ryan. I think Eli is overrated!

[steve18]

ryan in round six???? he is usually the 11th or 12th qb taken, u could of waited

It's a dynasty league and a keeper league. Drafting Brett Favre if he really retires next year means you have to fill your roster with someone else. The key is to draft younger players who are at their peak and will still most likely be playing in a few years.

It's not your ordinary 1 season league.

[bobbyk1133]

Matt Ryan. He's going to have a big year.

[EmpireMaker]

Matt Ryan

[Afrot69]

Matt Ryan here as well

[eberetta1]

Eli Manning would be my choice only because I have never heard of the other guy. I have family from Tennessee which is Eli's stomping grounds.

[onlooker]

Eli Manning would be my choice only because I have never heard of the other guy. I have family from Tennessee which is Eli's stomping grounds.

I think you better start paying more attention to the NFL.

[Bogart45]

I would pick Ryan.

[midoriwilleatyou]

i would definitely go with Matty Ice. He's going to have a great season if he stay's healthy.

[onlooker]

I had Ryan last season, and when he went out with turf toe, it killed my season.

[NardVa]

I like Matt Ryan. I think he 's gone take the next step and become and elite QB similar to the way Phillip Rivers and Aaron Rodgers did last year.

[LT Profits]

Easily Ryan, besides being the better quarterback, he also has better receivers to throw to.

[icancount2one]

Both are described as "elite quarterbacks" by ESPN so are equal. BOL.

[makemerich]

i say manning. if v.cruz gets on. td all day.