NFL Coach of the year? Who should it be?

[onlooker]

Here are three that should be on everyones list. Who out of them do you think will win the Coach of the Year award?

• Eric Mangini
• Sean Payton
• Andy Reid

[Illusion]

Andy Reid and the Eagles were left for dead sitting at 5-6. They also faced three striaght divional road games on the schedule with a backup quarterback. Well, they are in the playoffs and have a chance to win the NFC East. I think Reid deserves the award this year.

[mad]

You forgot one:

• mad

I'll just add it in here myself. Hope you don't mind.

[tacomax]

I vote for mad.

[mad]

Thanks taco.

How come you didn't make it this year?

[tacomax]

No-one nominated me, and I'm too respected to nominate myself.

[Ponies101]

Vote

I give my non-binding, non-relevant, newbie vote to Mangini. Sure, The Jets have only beaten 2 teams with winning records among their 9 wins, but when they got beat bad like against Jacksonville (0-41) and Buffalo (13-31), they came right back the next week and won games they had to.

[pags11]

I voted for Reid, but I think Fischer should also be considered...

[mad]

Well since taco was good enough to vote for me, i'll have to return the favour and nominate him.

New list reads as follows:

• Eric Mangini
• Sean Payton
• Andy Reid
• mad
• tacomax

Have i forgotten anyone?

[Willie Bee]

I voted for Reid, but I think Fischer should also be considered...

Agreed. I vote 'other' (Jeff Fisher, Tennessee).

[pags11]

willie, good choice...