Brady 3-2 in Super bowl, Elway 2-3 in Super bowl. Brady 8 Championship game Elway 6 Championship games. Elway edges Brady in every all time passing record. Elway also played in a league when the defense could brutalize you, plus he took two different Head coaches to the Superbowl. So when we get all this talk here about Brady being GOAT, his numbers are not that much better Elway.