NFL comeback player of the year Peyton Manning or Adrian peterson

[irish1]

This is another situation where either one could be a terrific choice. I'm leaning toward AD because running is a more difficult position to dominate. Both came back from career ending injuries. Peyton MVP and AD comeback player of the year

[mnwild11]

I think it will be determined by how each teams fare. Will be a more difficult decision if the vikes make the playoffs

[slacker00]

Manning for comeback, he missed an entire year with numerous neck surgeries and now playing with new team.

If Peterson can get the Vikings into the playoffs, forget comeback, he deserves the MVP.