If you're the A's, do you start Colon or Gray in Game 5?

[bambiankles]

yeah you gotta go with the steroids

[ezmoney]

Big mistake for Oakland starting Colon, 8-10 vs Det, 5.4 ERA. probably on short lease.

EZ

[BroncosBettor]

Starting Colon is absolutely the right thing to do. It's a one game season and if you lose, you go home. Why would you save him for a game that MIGHT happen. No brainer in my opinion to start him in this game.

[HOT WINGS]

As Tigers fan I am hoping we see Colon fat ass. Gray makes me a little more nervous.

[No coincidences]

As Tigers fan I am hoping we see Colon fat ass. Gray makes me a little more nervous.

Agree.

[HOT WINGS]

Agree.

Yeah I am not putting a single dollar on this game but will be heavily invested all the same. Time for Verlander to be the Ace and make his mark in Tigers history.*He has failed to consistently show up in big games but the time is now! Lets go!

[No coincidences]

Yeah I am not putting a single dollar on this game but will be heavily invested all the same. Time for Verlander to be the Ace and make his mark in Tigers history.*He has failed to consistently show up in big games but the time is now! Lets go!

[HOT WINGS]

Hope he has that Bender and Change both working. He is going to need them against this A's team.

[No coincidences]

Hope he has that Bender and Change both working. He is going to need them against this A's team.

Agree. Neither pitch has been as sharp as '11 or even '12.

[HOT WINGS]

Agree. Neither pitch has been as sharp as '11 or even '12.

Nope that's been his problem all year but he has had the bender working last few games. If he can get all 3 pitches working in same game good luck, but its been a problem all year. Had to rely on fastball way too much.

[No coincidences]

Nope that's been his problem all year but he has had the bender working last few games. If he can get all 3 pitches working in same game good luck, but its been a problem all year. Had to rely on fastball way too much.

Plus, his velocity is down.

I still think his blister issues from ST were never fully resolved.

[HOT WINGS]

Plus, his velocity is down.

I still think his blister issues from ST were never fully resolved.

Agreed he just pitched through it I think and prolonged it

[No coincidences]

Agreed he just pitched through it I think and prolonged it

I remember seeing Schilling talking about how something like that doesn't just go away unless you give it at least two fulls weeks of rest.

[imadegen]

According to mlbs schedule sonny gray is starting tomorrow

[imadegen]

This is confirmed. Sonny gray

[whtsox13]

Can't find an edge so gonna hedge. Taking DET in game 5 vs A's series wager

Nevermind. Starting Gray with Colon waiting in the wings is the right move. Riding out A's series wager now