Given the choice between these two only...

[TheFugitive]

Otherwise T.Hill. for reasons mentioned above by JIbby

And yes, I know Samuel does not have the numbers this year. But where were the forty 9ers be without him!

[Crusherrr]

CMC gonna get hurt again at some point. It's honestly insane the amount of snap's he is getting. Not touches, but snaps. They're asking for a big injury sadly

[stevenash]

CMC gonna get hurt again at some point. It's honestly insane the amount of snap's he is getting. Not touches, but snaps. They're asking for a big injury sadly

And when he's not getting touches, he's a blocking back.
The guy is literally involved in every play.

[blankoblanco]

The title is MVP, not MVPTHT.

If the "value" in MVP isn't to their team, then who else would it be to? The league? That just sounds like most advertisable/promotable player. Completely different thing. So I'm deeply curious as to what the hell you're talking about.

Again, if you're just replacing the word "valuable" with "outstanding" in your mind, I totally get that. See my previous comment. But if you're beholden to what the V actually stands for, which it sounds like it with your big dumb initial thing, then your angle doesn't make any sense to me.

[clockwise1965]

McCaffrey.

Because he has won me more money.

Best answer so far.

[Headsterx]

I know for the purposes of this thread it only 2 choices.....but......DEEBO SAMUEL IS A MF'N BEAST.
When I go the way of Robert "I am a douchebag liberal" DeNiro and I impregnate a girl 60 years my junior, his name will be DEEBO SAMUEL!

For whatever reasons Purdy seems to have more of a connection with Aiyuk than Deebo. But he made made some big plays last week and today. Niners have now been using him for punt returns and kickoffs to get him more touches. If they did this at the beginning of the season, oh my he would’ve some big numbers.

[pimike]

Mccaffery more well rounded can block can run and catch.

Hill just catch and fast

[Optional]

Mccaffery more well rounded can block can run and catch.

Hill just catch and fast

Seems to have a sharp football brain, not just a perfect route runner or athlete.