Should Roger Craig be in the HOF?

[stake1]

2:1 lead.
Time to call Peter King

[19th Hole]

.

Craig as Padres' manager (1978)

Pitcher / Manager

Born: February 17, 1930 (age 91) Durham, North Carolina

Batted: Right Threw: Right

July 17, 1955, for the Brooklyn Dodgers

July 10, 1966, for the Philadelphia Phillies

74–98

3.83

803

738–737

.500

As player Brooklyn / Los Angeles Dodgers (1955–1961) New York Mets (1962–1963) St. Louis Cardinals (1964) Cincinnati Reds (1965) Philadelphia Phillies (1966) As manager San Diego Padres (1978–1979) San Francisco Giants (1985–1992) As coach San Diego Padres (1969–1972; 1976–1977) Houston Astros (1974–1975) Detroit Tigers (1980–1984)

4× World Series champion (1955, 1959, 1964, 1984)

.

[Chi_archie]

nah

halls of pretty good

put some shoes or his jock from the 1000 rushing/receiving year in the a display

otherwise he had a total of 3 seasons rushing for 1k

1502
1054
1050


give me a list of HOF RBs that have only 3 1k seasons or a 3 best seasons total of 3600 yards and I'll think more about it

[The Kraken]

Statistically, there are worse RB’s with fewer championships in the hof

There are also better rb’s that aren’t in yet

So he’s 50/50 for me

Really what stands out most is his three rings, and that he was a part of the og west coast offense. As I pointed out on my apt account, his stats are meh

[KVB]

nah

halls of pretty good

put some shoes or his jock from the 1000 rushing/receiving year in the a display

otherwise he had a total of 3 seasons rushing for 1k

1502
1054
1050


give me a list of HOF RBs that have only 3 1k seasons or a 3 best seasons total of 3600 yards and I'll think more about it

It wouldn't be right if you didn't then add in all purpose yards and then compare those to the HOF RB's you want to compare.

Maybe the problem here is that to make Craig an RB HOFer and want to compare him to other RB's but don't want to consider other stats than rushing yards.

Not sure of that's a good way to approach it.

[The Kraken]

He was Marshal Faulk 1.0

[Chi_archie]

if you wanna go by all purpose


then we'd be talking about putting a whole bunch of RB's in before him

Tiki Barber
Warrick Dunn
Steven Jackson
Lashawn McCoy
James Brooks
Ricky Waters
Matt Forte
Fred Taylor
Ahman Green
Corey Dillon
Maurice Jones Drew

are just some of the guys with more combined yards. It's very good, it's just not rare air achievement that should typify a hall of famer

[jtoler]

nah

halls of pretty good

put some shoes or his jock from the 1000 rushing/receiving year in the a display

otherwise he had a total of 3 seasons rushing for 1k

1502
1054
1050


give me a list of HOF RBs that have only 3 1k seasons or a 3 best seasons total of 3600 yards and I'll think more about it

lenny moore never had over 650 rushing yds in a season considered a halfback/flanker. I didn’t vote in poll not sure wut the correct answer or if there is one but I know sf offense was very good and I think defense was pretty good too it’d prob been hard not to shine in that offense