Does Madison Bumgarner make it to the hall of fame?

[pilebuck13]

I say he should what about you

[funnyb25]

No.

[pilebuck13]

Pitchers have it the hardest I swear guy was so clutch when it counted

[funnyb25]

How many Cy Young awards does he have?

[unlearn]

If he buys a ticket

[jrgum3]

I'm a Giants fan and I'm a huge Bumgarner fan but I don't think he gets in. He might go down as one of the best postseason pitchers of all time but I don't think that'll be enough to get him into the HOF.

[vitterd]

Hard to say. He’s remarkable in the post season but not dominant in regular season. He has comparable numbers to some guys that are already in.....but it’s probably gonna be a no.

[pilebuck13]

I tend to measure greatness in games that matter it’s a shame they don’t take this more into account

[cincinnatikid513]

why not

[slayer14]

Why did he go to arizona of all teams

[cincinnatikid513]

Why did he go to arizona of all teams

show me the money

[pilebuck13]

Should have went to Tampa for a small amount and chance at a ring

[pilebuck13]

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=wTy_p-vW5CU

Someone embed this greatness

[Otters27]

Should because he could hit too

[Stallion]

No chance

[jjgold]

Not even remotely close

Buck you drunk?

[Chi_archie]

yeah, go ahead and put him in with Gio Gonzalez, Johnny Cueto, and Jose Quintana

[pilebuck13]

yeah, go ahead and put him in with Gio Gonzalez, Johnny Cueto, and Jose Quintana

Those 2 names don’t even belong in the same sentence as bum come on Archie

[CanuckG]

0.0% chance

[SBR_Guest_Pro]

Nope

[MinnesotaFats]

Not even close

Great postseason runs for a 5 year stretch, but the career isn't very impressive, the WAR isn't impressive and he doesn't have any personal hardware/ awards

[ThaTopMoron]

I tend to measure greatness in games that matter it’s a shame they don’t take this more into account

pile told me he thinks dan marino was a bum

[pilebuck13]

pile told me he thinks dan marino was a bum

Me personally can’t throw your name in the hat unless you win a big one

[mtneer1212]

Zero chance. He is 120-96 lifetime. He has never finished in the top 3 for Cy Young voting. If he wins another 100 games, and a Cy Young or two, he could be in consideration..... but as of now, he isn't even a fringe contender.

[DrunkHorseplayer]

Tough call, which means the answer is probably no.

[rm18]

His ERA and WHIP are better than Nolan Ryan and he hit 19 homers and a postseason legend. Lynn Swann made NFL HOF off playoffs only he barely caught a ball in the regular season.

[pilebuck13]

His ERA and WHIP are better than Nolan Ryan and he hit 19 homers and a postseason legend. Lynn Swann made NFL HOF off playoffs only he barely caught a ball in the regular season.

These baseball purists are wack jobs war is all that matters to them

[goduke]

He’s in 100 percent. Might be the greatest postseason pitcher ever

[Wrongside]

What are his political beliefs? Factor that in...

[Orbison]

i'm more interested to see if he shows up in shape and can get his velocity back, he fell off a cliff last year but there were red flags towards the end of his Giants tenure

[Bcatswin]

Not even close

[pologq]

i'm more interested to see if he shows up in shape and can get his velocity back, he fell off a cliff last year but there were red flags towards the end of his Giants tenure

i think all of his years have caught up. he has to be more crafty.

as of now i don't think he gets into the hall of fame.

[Chi_archie]

Those 2 names don’t even belong in the same sentence as bum come on Archie

they they have nearly identical stats and accomplishments

that is how dumb it is to think Bumgarner will even get even 10% of the votes needed

[smitch124]

He got off to a good start towards it, but 2014 was 7 years ago. What has he done since?

[slayer14]

Guy going to have a terrible season