Greatest 3 quarterbacks and most overrated 3 ?

[The General]

Manning underrated is a farce. He hasn't had a real good defense in any year.

[reno cool]

What injuries? The guy (Marino) is all time leader in longevity. Passes, completions, yards etc.
But yeah, Montana was the best in the last 30 years, easily

[ABEHONEST]

What injuries? The guy (Marino) is all time leader in longevity. Passes, completions, yards etc.
But yeah, Montana was the best in the last 30 years, easily

Thanks RENO !
I guess I can go to sleep now that DWIGHT has been proven wrong !

[DwightShrute]

Thanks RENO !
I guess I can go to sleep now that DWIGHT has been proven wrong !

let's call it a draw (I am being very generous here)

[Shortstop]

My secretary at my last job did yayo with Marino at Pitt. True story.

[ABEHONEST]

My secretary at my last job did yayo with Marino at Pitt. True story.

Is yayo a computer game ?

[RonPaul2008]

Top 3 since 1980
________________
Montana
Young
Elway

[RonPaul2008]

Most Overrrated QB since 1980
_____________________________

Dan Marino

[SPECULATOR 13]

montana ??

Sorry ABE i took so long to answer,i have been over my head for a while now

Abe take Montana put him with the Dolphins and he becomes Dave Krieg
Need i ask you for the reverse put Dan with the Steelers of the mid-70's or with the 49ers of the 80's up to 1997 he might have won 10 SB.

[BGS 9.5]

Montana
Unitas
Favre

Second part will require more thought...

[BGS 9.5]

Overrated:

Vick
McNabb
Joe Wille

[DwightShrute]

Sorry ABE i took so long to answer,i have been over my head for a while now

Abe take Montana put him with the Dolphins and he becomes Dave Krieg
Need i ask you for the reverse put Dan with the Steelers of the mid-70's or with the 49ers of the 80's up to 1997 he might have won 10 SB.

voice of reason!

[MadTiger]

My Top 4
Jason Campbell
Mark Rypien
Doug Williams
Joe Theismann

Most Overrated
Tony Romo
Quincy Carter
Troy Aikman
Roger Staubach

Strong 'Skins vs The Boys bigotry.

Nice try, though.

[brooks85]

Ill tell you what is overrated, fascist regimes built through capitalism.
11 games on today and none are nationally broadcast, thats just irritating.

Lucky for me tho, i get cle/det game

[frostno98]

Greatest
Elway 5 Superbowls
Montana 4 Superbowls
Brady 4 Superbowls

Overrated
Steve Young
Troy Aikman
Big Ben

[ABEHONEST]

Greatest
Elway 5 Superbowls
Montana 4 Superbowls
Brady 4 Superbowls

Overrated
Steve Young
Troy Aikman
Big Ben

Well duh, Mr. Frostno98 !

Montana has 4 SUPERBOWL wins,and ELWAY has 2 ,also ,when MONTANA and ELWAY met in SUPERBOWL X1X,guess who won ?

MONTANA beat ELWAY like a drum,55/10,largest margin of victory ever !

[frostno98]

Well duh, Mr. Frostno98 !

Montana has 4 SUPERBOWL wins,and ELWAY has 2 ,also ,when MONTANA and ELWAY met in SUPERBOWL X1X,guess who won ?

MONTANA beat ELWAY like a drum,55/10,largest margin of victory ever !

Yeah, but look who Montana had on that freaking team!

Hall of Famer Ronnie Lott, the greatest reciever ever Jerry Rice, Roger Craig who just had a 2,000 yard season rushing and receiving combined. Against a one man gang in Elway. C'mon what you expect, Steve Bono the 49er's 3rd stringer would of won that game.

[StraitShooter]

Top 3

Fouts

Staubach

Griese


over rated

Marino-Namath-Ken Anderson (Cinci)

[StraitShooter]

Dan Fouts had practically no one special and made no ones special

Maybe charlie Joiner/ Wes Chandler..and Don Woods looked like he would be a great rb until he fell off the planet

[ABEHONEST]

Yeah, but look who Montana had on that freaking team!

Hall of Famer Ronnie Lott, the greatest reciever ever Jerry Rice, Roger Craig who just had a 2,000 yard season rushing and receiving combined. Against a one man gang in Elway. C'mon what you expect, Steve Bono the 49er's 3rd stringer would of won that game.

Yeah, MONTANA made those guy's look great didn't he ?

[twentyonekid]

Top 3

unitas

montana

elway


bottom 3

jim kelly

daunte culpepper

dan fouts

[Bigmikesm]

1. Bernie Kosar
2. Jim Kelly
3. Vinny Testdeverde

[biggamerife21]

Top 3-
Elway
Farve
Manning

Overated-
McNabb(he gives away games for fun)
Phil Simms
Vick

Underated-
Mark Brunell- pre washed up
Pennington
Jeff Garcia

[yisman]

People today don't seem to know about Otto Graham and Sid Luckman.

[dlunc3]

have i really seen brady's name numorous times as overrated??

[Pete0]

2011


Top 3 :

Brady
Rodgers
Cam Newton


Most Overrated :

Sanchez
Eli Manning
Big Ben

[VegasInsider]

How is Tom Brady overrated? That makes no sense..

Top 3

Montana
Brady
P Manning

Overrated

Roethisberger
McNabb
Kelly

[VegasInsider]

have i really seen brady's name numorous times as overrated??

It's only because they probably hate the Patriots. There is ZERO argument for Brady being overrated.

[KKoz9]

My Top 4
Jason Campbell
Mark Rypien
Doug Williams
Joe Theismann

Most Overrated
Tony Romo
Quincy Carter
Troy Aikman
Roger Staubach

funny, are you a Skins fan?

[Glitch]

best:
montana
elway
unitas
honorable mention: favre

overrated:
aikman
aikman
aikman

current best: peyton, brady, brees
current overrated: romo, cutler, rivers

[face]

brady is an awesome QB, will definitely go down as one of the greatest
people will not know the name phillip rivers in ten years.

[zuluhead1``1]

Top:
Montana
Starr
Unitas

Overratted:
Manning
Favre
Namath


Most underrated:
Ken Stabler. He should be in the HOF

[(Reyes)]

MONTANA

[odog11]

Not sure about this, but do people seriously think Elway and Favre are better than Brady? I just don't see anyway to make the arguement for either. Same thing for Manning, clearly better than those 2.

[upscope]

top:
montana
manning
brady

overrated:
vick
mcnabb
namath