Need help......Fantasy football question

[Marigold HD]

Who would you rather have:

Dynasty....

Christian McCaffrey or Jonathon Taylor and Swift

Because help with details.

[jjgold]

Caffy

Stat machine

[pologq]

who are your other running backs right now?

[Marigold HD]

who are your other running backs right now?

Gaskin
D Freeman
Gore
Davis (cmc backup)

[Marigold HD]

Gaskin
D Freeman
Gore
Davis (cmc backup)

It was an auction draft. I overspent on cmc. Rest of runningbacks

[Mr. Teaser]

Christian McCaffrey

[Heltah Skeltah]

How is your team this year? You in the hunt for a ship.
Going forward in a dynasty thats not a bad deal for u getting 2 young rb that are taking over their backfields for the future. If you not in contention then that trade definitely helps you get younger moving forward . CMC is tough to give up though..maybe ask for a young wr or te that could add for u also

[Marigold HD]

I'm 3-4 going into week 8

[shadymcgrady]

If it's round or auction based keepers then go with Taylor easy

[Marigold HD]

If it's round or auction based keepers then go with Taylor easy

Taylor and swift

[chico2663]

Who would you rather have:

Dynasty....

Christian McCaffrey or Jonathon Taylor and Swift

Because help with details.

Mccaffrey. He will score more than the 2 combined.

[chico2663]

Also there are Taylor and swift in Every year’s draft. But there’s a McCaffrey only once every five or six years!

[Stallion]

Mccaffrey, then Taylor.

[pologq]

sorry just saw this now.

i would stick with CMC. you have gaskin who i think will develop nicely. that is a good pick.

you have CMC's backup as a fail safe anyway so you are still getting the panthers RB points if/when CMC gets hurt. not like you are scrambling too badly when CMC gets hurt.

[shadymcgrady]

Sry glazed over dynasty, I'm assuming that's no penalty or round lost or auction cash spent on players kept?

Dynasty values are volatile and tend to favor young wr, fluctuating greatly year over year. Tomorrow's randy moss could be worthless next season.

In a vacuum I'd prioritize taylor first, Indy's I line is top 5 in the league and still ascending. Whether rivers is there or not next yr they will lean on the run regardless of who is at qb and you have taylor from the start providing the most dynasty value.

Cmc is alrdy a big name and while he's great he's not a generational talent like ladainian tomlinson or marshall faulk were for their owners. I'd look to sell on him while his value is at its Apex if you can get a kings ransom from a fanboy. He'll still be valuable but the point is to buy low and sell high so it's a toss up.

Swift is okay but keeping him over the other two implies that he has to hit his potential just to break even or pay off which is a lousy investment. Detroit's line is decent and improving granted the staff stays in place but that's a big if and alot of moving parts.

[mpaschal34]

Taylor Swift...just sounds like a losing team.

[Marigold HD]

The original question was

cmc

Or

Both swift and Taylor

[Unrivaled]

McCaffrey by a mile.

[shadymcgrady]

Dynasty leagues are usually all about predicting the next CMC. Everyone saying cmc wouldn't be buying alphabet or Amazon stock today when they should've bought it at 1/10th of the value yesterday

[pologq]

Dynasty leagues are usually all about predicting the next CMC. Everyone saying cmc wouldn't be buying alphabet or Amazon stock today when they should've bought it at 1/10th of the value yesterday

i don't think either of the RB's in that trade are the next CMC honestly. i think he having gaskin is very under the radar.

[7deuceoff$uit]

CMC, but i do like swift. Sounds like a good problem to have.