Elephant in the room... David Lee or Sammy Hagar?

[Shute]

RIP
Great guitar player
He could play

[Eddy Munny]

Too soon.

[gauchojake]

Diamond Dave by a fukkin country mile

[Shute]

Too soon.

Not
Everywhere I got I’m hearing Van Halen
Everywhere

[Kermit]

There are songs that I liked by each of them. I'd probably give the edge to Diamond Dave.

[jjgold]

Roth

[mjsuax13]

Small edge Sammy. Dave better partier. Sammy music more polished.

[Ian]

Gary Cherone

[Shute]

Sammy
No doubt

[The General]

The better entertainer was david not even close, imo.

[cincinnatikid513]

jimmy

[stake1]

Hagar definitely croaks before Diamond Dave

[mpaschal34]

I was very anti-Sammy early on...refused for listen to anything with him. However as I got older I learned to appreciate what he contributed to the band.

However, Gary Cherone was unacceptable.

[Eddy Munny]

Not
Everywhere I got I’m hearing Van Halen
Everywhere

Playing Van Halen is not too soon, asking dumb questions is too soon.

[The General]

Eddie was a bad ass guitar man. Just like Robert Montgomery Knight was a bad ass hoops coach.

[Brock Landers]

Roth was a showman, could barely sing

Sammy was a great singer and they made a fortune with him

its a tie

[Johnnythunder]

David Lee because 1984 is easily their best

[MinnesotaFats]

Sammy by far. The better music overall came during his tenure

[jjgold]

Roth gave the band world wide recognition

[pologq]

i prefer Hagar but Roth was better at giving a performance as mentioned

[nyplayer33]

Hagar had that one great song. When its love..video was in a bar i think..great song

[stevek173]

David Gilmour

[franklee168]

Angus Young or Eddie Van Halen?

[DrunkHorseplayer]

Showmanship: DLR
Musicianship: The Red Rocker

I'll give it to Dave because the music had a harder edge.

[EmpireMaker]

David Lee Roth

[stake1]

I’ve got $500 on Hagar as next Caucasian rock singer in my death pool. Natural or suicide

[CMNoney]

Roth.

Jump is a top 10 song all time.

[clockwise1965]

I like Hager. Roth was an a hole

[Art Vandelay]

Roth = The true definition of "frontman". He had the perfect persona for their style.

[thechaoz]

Diamond Dave by a fukkin country mile

It's not even close

[Kermit]

Fav Dave song:

Fav Sammy song:

[KVB]

Legends.

[KVB]

[beavis13]