Is Aaron Rodgers the GOAT quarterback in the NFL today?
After KC plays Balty, people will change their minds maybe.
Roscoe_Word
SBR MVP
02-28-12
3999
#2
He's lighting it up; but the guy from KC is still the defending champ.
Comment
Eddy Munny
SBR Posting Legend
08-13-13
15768
#3
It's Nick Foles. He led the Bears to a dramatic come from behind win on the road, fresh outta the bullpen.
He also has as many Super Bowl rings as Arod.
Comment
jjgold
SBR Aristocracy
07-20-05
388179
#4
Rogers a Hall of Famer
Comment
DrunkHorseplayer
SBR Hall of Famer
05-15-10
7719
#5
Look at the Pack's record with him vs. without him; he's been easily the best in the league since Peyton Manning's neck injury.
Comment
Roscoe_Word
SBR MVP
02-28-12
3999
#6
Originally posted by Eddy Munny
It's Nick Foles. He led the Bears to a dramatic come from behind win on the road, fresh outta the bullpen.
He also has as many Super Bowl rings as Arod.
Always a sharp and witty perspective.
Comment
Fred The Hammer
SBR Posting Legend
08-13-13
11582
#7
Originally posted by Eddy Munny
It's Nick Foles. He led the Bears to a dramatic come from behind win on the road, fresh outta the bullpen.
He also has as many Super Bowl rings as Arod.
Cmon Eddy? You're better then that. Only casual no-nothing fans think it comes down to nothing but rings. I remember teasing a buddy that loved Michael Jordan that Jordan had no rings for many years and other guys were better. I knew he was the greatest I'd ever seen. These young guys today might not realize how long it took Jordan to get his first ring!
Rodgers is the most talented QB of all time! Not his fault that GBs coaching/front office doesn't know wtf they're doing. Lost to Kurt Warner one year like 45-43. GBs defense SINGLEHANDEDLY made Krapernick a household name. Look at last year....same shit. SF ran over their defense like Ohio State against Toledo. That shouldn't be happening in the NFL, but thats what GB does. They made the NFLs final 4 and draft a penetrating QB and RB with their first 2 picks?? W T F are they doing up there? Rodgers needs to walk so he can get another ring. Please come to Indy and we'll get you another ring!
Comment
Fred The Hammer
SBR Posting Legend
08-13-13
11582
#8
Originally posted by jjgold
Rogers a Hall of Famer
Alot of QBs are HOFers. Rodgers is the GOAT. He could do what Brady has done and more. With his mobility NE could've been even better. He's so good that Belechik would give up cheating
Comment
Fred The Hammer
SBR Posting Legend
08-13-13
11582
#9
Rodgers last 10 years counting 2020 so far:
286 TDs 52 picks
Think about that for a second. GBs had no running game until 2019 so THEY KNEW HE HAD TO PASS and he still averaged only 5 picks per season. He just doesn't turn it over. Period.
Comment
hawkwind
SBR MVP
04-25-11
4069
#10
NO A Very Good QB top 5
Comment
Roscoe_Word
SBR MVP
02-28-12
3999
#11
It must be reminded that the best QB is the one who covers the spread.
Comment
Fred The Hammer
SBR Posting Legend
08-13-13
11582
#12
Originally posted by hawkwind
NO A Very Good QB top 5
Only one you could argue is better is Brady. Nobody else is in the discussion
They both average about 260 yds per game in their careers. Brady 547 tds 182 picks (3 tds per pick) Rodgers 373 tds 84 picks (4.4 tds per pick). I also guarantee NE is atleast 8+ points per game better on defense. GB has never had a lockdown defense in Rodgers career. Maybe a B grade defense at best when they won the SB
Comment
rm18
SBR Posting Legend
09-20-05
22291
#13
He is the best ever but today the is 3rd at best.
Comment
Fred The Hammer
SBR Posting Legend
08-13-13
11582
#14
Originally posted by rm18
He is the best ever but today the is 3rd at best.
Mahomes looked horrible last week. I love watching him play, but his fundamentals are terrible sometimes. He throws off his back foot, etc. and counts on his cannon arm. He's got to clean that up long-term because the cannon arm doesn't usually last forever.
Russell Wilson is unreal, but if he had Aaron Jones then he'd run more and if AR had Seattle's WRs then he'd throw 3-4 TDs every week. Lamar Jackson? We'll see? Krapernick looked great for a short while. Vick looked really good for a while too
Comment
Fred The Hammer
SBR Posting Legend
08-13-13
11582
#15
Hard to argue against Mahomes so far though
Averaging 300 passing per game (40 more then Rodgers/Brady) and 81 tds 18 picks (4.5 tds to picks) even slightly better then Rodgers ratio
Comment
KVB
SBR Aristocracy
05-29-14
74817
#16
It's good to see Rogers maintaining and not falling off. He is one of the most entertaining to watch.
Comment
rm18
SBR Posting Legend
09-20-05
22291
#17
Originally posted by Fred The Hammer
Mahomes looked horrible last week. I love watching him play, but his fundamentals are terrible sometimes. He throws off his back foot, etc. and counts on his cannon arm. He's got to clean that up long-term because the cannon arm doesn't usually last forever.
Russell Wilson is unreal, but if he had Aaron Jones then he'd run more and if AR had Seattle's WRs then he'd throw 3-4 TDs every week. Lamar Jackson? We'll see? Krapernick looked great for a short while. Vick looked really good for a while too
I got Mahomes 4th. Lot of weapons and good play calling. Lamar or Russ is close right now.
Comment
manny24
SBR Posting Legend
10-22-07
20046
#18
G ay
O r
A pparent
T wink
100%
Comment
Fred The Hammer
SBR Posting Legend
08-13-13
11582
#19
Originally posted by KVB
It's good to see Rogers maintaining and not falling off. He is one of the most entertaining to watch.
Yeah he's amazing! I can see some decline in mobility. He used to run around all day like Russ WIlson, but the arm is 90% of premium and the accuracy/timing is as good as ever.
Comment
Fred The Hammer
SBR Posting Legend
08-13-13
11582
#20
NFC is wide open? Seattle no defense. GB not much defense. Saints are done imo. Brees is washed up. Said that last year when the Saints played better with Bridgewater. SF wiped out by injury. Tampa might have the best overall team on paper when Brady figures out the system. Goff is balling this year too. They came back from 28-3 and should've won that game yesterday.
Rams, Bucs, GB, and Seattle....pick one out of a hat
Comment
Kermit
BARRELED IN @ SBR!
09-27-10
32555
#21
Russell Wilson
Comment
pologq
SBR Posting Legend
10-07-12
19899
#22
rodgers makes his WR's look a lot better than they are (except Adams). def one of the best and he is never out of a game.
Comment
PAULYPOKER
BARRELED IN @ SBR!
12-06-08
36581
#23
Hard to say as there has never been this many great QB's in the same era as what we see today in the NFL,
from young bucks to old men still lighting it up.
In no particular order, the best QB's in NFL are:
Brady,Wilson,Rodgers,Brees,Roethlisberge r,Jackson,Mahomes,
If we are just going from last season thru this season the Goat is Resilient Wilson across the board as he's been killing it in every category.
Comment
lakerboy
SBR Aristocracy
04-02-09
94379
#24
Chip on shoulder this year because they drafted herbert. That was an actual genius move. He will wear down though.
Comment
shadymcgrady
SBR Posting Legend
02-27-12
10036
#25
It's been Russell wilson for 2 yrs
Comment
Snowball
BARRELED IN @ SBR!
11-15-09
30058
#26
Originally posted by PAULYPOKER
Hard to say as there has never been this many great QB's in the same era as what we see today in the NFL,
from young bucks to old men still lighting it up.
In no particular order, the best QB's in NFL are:
Brady,Wilson,Rodgers,Brees,Roethlisberge r,Jackson,Mahomes,
If we are just going from last season thru this season the Goat is Resilient Wilson across the board as he's been killing it in every category.
They only perform better statistically because everything has changed.
Comment
manny24
SBR Posting Legend
10-22-07
20046
#27
TB12 you fukkin cokkroaches
Comment
PAULYPOKER
BARRELED IN @ SBR!
12-06-08
36581
#28
Originally posted by Snowball
They only perform better statistically because everything has changed.
True...
Also athleticism has evolved from cavemen to cyborgs in last 50 years.
Comment
PAULYPOKER
BARRELED IN @ SBR!
12-06-08
36581
#29
25 years ago you were lucky to find good productive WR's who could actually catch the ball.
Today WR's are a dime a dozen who can catch the ball with one hand.
Same with QB's as you were lucky to find a QB who could consistently throw the ball close enough
to give the WR a chance to catch the ball.
Today QB's are a dime a dozen who can throw the ball into a mailbox from anywhere on the field.
Comment
Unrivaled
SBR Hall of Famer
10-24-11
6685
#30
Most talented ever in his prime but today no he is 3rd best in the NFL.
Comment
stevenash
Moderator
01-17-11
65679
#31
Originally posted by Fred The Hammer
Alot of QBs are HOFers. Rodgers is the GOAT. He could do what Brady has done and more. With his mobility NE could've been even better. He's so good that Belechik would give up cheating
Montana > Rodgers
Comment
stevenash
Moderator
01-17-11
65679
#32
Originally posted by shadymcgrady
It's been Russell wilson for 2 yrs
And he's so consistent too.
What you see in Wilson is almost what your'e going to get.
Comment
darrell74
SBR Posting Legend
04-16-07
14648
#33
Look at the schedule
13+ wins easy money
Comment
maxell
SBR Sharp
06-09-14
397
#34
It's a little too early to be anointing Mahomes. Let him extend his legacy to 5-7 years and see where he's at.
Comment
KVB
SBR Aristocracy
05-29-14
74817
#35
I'd say KC already annointed Mahomes and Auto with $400+ million and a potential piece of the Royals.