Nfl is eli manning hof ??

[nyplayer33]

I day no...but they won 2x and he was mvp in both of the super bowks plus hes a nyg

[RudyRuetigger]

i dont think so

but he will get in

[cincinnatikid513]

of course, if rivers is gettting in manning must too

[Louisvillekid1]

i dont think so

but he will get in

Yeah it’s close, but I’m on the fence

doesn’t matter as he is a lock to get In

[big joe 1212]

add in that he's also been named man of the year. class act on and off the field

i say yes

[SBR_Guest_Pro]

of course, if rivers is gettting in manning must too

Rivers has better numbers than manning though...

[CMNoney]

Whether people think he deserves to get in or he doesn't, it's honestly the dumbest argument in all of sports.

He is a LOCK to get in. Probably even on the 1st ballot.

He's top 10 all time in passing yards and passing TD's. He won 2 Super Bowls and 2 Super Bowl MVP's. There are only 4 other players in NFL history who won multiple Super Bowl MVP's: Tom Brady, Joe Montana, Bart Starr and Terry Bradshaw. All in the Hall of Fame.

[jjgold]

Two lucky wins but he made some big plays

[CMNoney]

Rivers has better numbers than manning though...

With zero defining moments in his entire career....

Eli won 2 Super Bowls and was the MVP in both of those Super Bowls. WINNING MATTERS.

[GzaTheGenius]

Yes first ballot

Guy was 2x super bowl MVP

Took down arguably the best franchise of all time twice.

One of the best all time in 4th quarter comebacks

Never missed a game

Guy is a legend

[SBR_Guest_Pro]

With zero defining moments in his entire career....

Eli won 2 Super Bowls and was the MVP in both of those Super Bowls. WINNING MATTERS.

When it comes to HOF, it's all about the numbers and science

[big joe 1212]

Rivers NO
Eli YES

[Hman]

Everyone else gets in so why not

[19th Hole]

Will Eli get the HOF nod?
Yes
Is he deserving?
NO

But this is personal judgement by all chiming in.

[SBR_Guest_Pro]

Rivers NO
Eli YES

Rivers is guaranteed. Due to the numbers. One of the best QB's of our lifetime

[RudyRuetigger]

Rivers is guaranteed. Due to the numbers. One of the best QB's of our lifetime

Bro I am about ready to kick you out of the republican party with that statement

[Hman]

Will Eli get the HOF nod?
Yes
Is he deserving?
NO

But this is personal judgement by all chiming in.

Only about 20% are deserving

Should be reserved for only the greatest

[clockwise1965]

Nope

[Hot Jerry]

rivers no
eli yes

agree !!

[DiggityDaggityDo]

Only about 20% are deserving

Should be reserved for only the greatest

Yup

If Joe Namath can get in, Eli can get in.

[SBR_Guest_Pro]

Bro I am about ready to kick you out of the republican party with that statement

Keep in mind, my lifetime is has been a lot shorter of a time span than your life time

[Slurry Pumper]

I think he gets in. He is one of the best post season QBs ever and he does have 2 rings with one coming against a previously undefeated team. His regular season stats don't warrant it but the post season does. he doesn't get in right away however it will take a good 10 years for him.

[seaborneq]

Think about what you asking here?? AB and Big Ben will get in too and they were terrible off the field, but on the field greatness will win out. Of course there will be two Mannings in the Hall of Fame. If archie lives long enough the senior committee will put him in just for shooting out sperm for both of them.

[Louisvillekid1]

Rivers is guaranteed. Due to the numbers. One of the best QB's of our lifetime

I’d like to compare his number to Jamesis

I bet they are similar

[hawkwind]

They'll put him in but the answer is NO