if Cam Newton Retires now, Is he a Hall of Famer?

[Big Bear]

Yes or No

thanks men

[mgcolby]

No...

[jjgold]

Not even close

He might get in because he’s black that new thing now to treat them like pussies

[Sam Odom]

Bear Relax

Staff are reviewing your posts

[BeatTheJerk]

No.

[dlowilly]

Clown Hall of Fame maybe

[Sam Odom]

[mgcolby]

Did he fall asleep at a bus stop in the rain and have an elderly lady try to cover him up?

[pologq]

No. Needs another couple of good seasons imo.

[Goat Milk]

No. Needs another couple of good seasons imo.

A couple?

BigBear, this is one of your worst threads lol.

Newton has a 0% chance at the hall of fame.

Not even Phillip Rivers will get in.

Eli Manning himself is very borderline. A lot of ppl will say no to him.

[2daBank]

Bear Relax

Staff are reviewing your posts

What a horrible job. Can you imagine having to read all this morons post? Jfc, think I would slice my wrist.

[2daBank]

A couple?

BigBear, this is one of your worst threads lol.

Newton has a 0% chance at the hall of fame.

Not even Phillip Rivers will get in.

Eli Manning himself is very borderline. A lot of ppl will say no to him.

I say no to Eli but he a lead pipe lock.


Rivers will prob get in eventually. It’s not the HOF anymore. It the hall of pretty good.

All bears threads are equally dog shit, this one is no different. He a panthers homer why he posting this trash.

[44 Mag]

I say no to Eli but he a lead pipe lock.


Rivers will prob get in eventually. It’s not the HOF anymore. It the hall of pretty good.

All bears threads are equally dog shit, this one is no different. He a panthers homer why he posting this trash.

My Man !!!! Rivers ????? "Come on Man". LOL. In that case: Vinny Testaverde.

[2daBank]

My Man !!!! Rivers ????? "Come on Man". LOL. In that case: Vinny Testaverde.

I agree w you but watch. He will get more votes every year and prob make it before he leaves the ballet. Hall of kinda good. He a numbers accumulator, they usually get in even tho the numbers are fraudulent these days.

[POOLSIDE]

Eli is getting in. He stopped the perfect season for the Pats and then repeated against them in the Super Bowl. He’s in.

[SBR Tony]

hall of fame where ?

[mgcolby]

Eli is getting in. He stopped the perfect season for the Pats and then repeated against them in the Super Bowl. He’s in.

If he gets in...which because of those two wins he probably will...he should have Asante Samual and Mario Manningham be his Co-Presenters.

[MinnesotaFats]

LOL. NO

Randall Cunningham would have to go in before any other moderately successful "physical" QB like Vick, McNsir or McNabb

[stevek173]

Not even close.

[MinnesotaFats]

Manning is not in...

.500 as starter, mediocre yards, low tds, low comp %, lots of picks, low rating

Simms, Anderson, Eisason and Cunningham better QBs

Manning never even all pro or mvp

[2daBank]

Manning is not in...

.500 as starter, mediocre yards, low tds, low comp %, lots of picks, low rating

Simms, Anderson, Eisason and Cunningham better QBs

Manning never even all pro or mvp

How many mvp does cousins have? Care to bet? I’ll give you +200 on Manning not getting in. He a lock. Can’t stand him but unlike your boy he a winner, didn’t choke in the big moments.

[Booya711]

Hall of fame voting is almost as bad as a participation trophy nowadays.....

[2daBank]

Hall of fame voting is almost as bad as a participation trophy nowadays.....

Exactly. Hall of kinda good.

[Goat Milk]

I say no to Eli but he a lead pipe lock.


Rivers will prob get in eventually. It’s not the HOF anymore. It the hall of pretty good.

All bears threads are equally dog shit, this one is no different. He a panthers homer why he posting this trash.

There’s only like 350 ppl in the hall I think? Was there this year. Very selective.

[Goat Milk]

Hall of fame voting is almost as bad as a participation trophy nowadays.....

Tons of great players haven’t made the nfl hall of fame

[2daBank]

There’s only like 350 ppl in the hall I think? Was there this year. Very selective.

No it’s not. There a whole bunch of decent players not great in it.

[LT Profits]

Newton is not even an afterthought for Hall, why would he be?

[2daBank]

Newton is not even an afterthought for Hall, why would he be?

Cause bear a idiot and jerks off to his poster.

[Goat Milk]

No it’s not. There a whole bunch of decent players not great in it.

Who was decent that was post 1980 that made it? Because before that yeah it wasn't selective obviously. But I'd like to hear an example of let's say a guy who retired in 2005 who was just "decent" who made it.

[2daBank]

Who was decent that was post 1980 that made it? Because before that yeah it wasn't selective obviously. But I'd like to hear an example of let's say a guy who retired in 2005 who was just "decent" who made it.

Just for you buddy. Since 2005:

Warren Moon
Tim brown
Charlie Sanders (who?)
Gary Zimmerman
Andre Tippett
Fred dean
Floyd little
Ricky Jackson
Willie roaf
Curtis Martin (stat accumulator)
Chris doleman
Michael Strathan
Jayson Taylor
Kenny easly
Morton Anderson
Brian Dawkins


I’m not even including the guys that didn’t play in 80s so I can’t say 1st hand. And I’m being very generous not including more. Nothing against these guys. All very good players but not exactly the greatest of the great by any stretch.

[Brock Landers]

Does a chicken have lips??

[Big Bear]

Newton is not even an afterthought for Hall, why would he be?

guy on the radio today said he would be on the fringe

says 1 more playoff appearance would solidify it

[Goat Milk]

Just for you buddy. Since 2005:

Warren Moon
Tim brown
Charlie Sanders (who?)
Gary Zimmerman
Andre Tippett
Fred dean
Floyd little
Ricky Jackson
Willie roaf
Curtis Martin (stat accumulator)
Chris doleman
Michael Strathan
Jayson Taylor
Kenny easly
Morton Anderson
Brian Dawkins


I’m not even including the guys that didn’t play in 80s so I can’t say 1st hand. And I’m being very generous not including more. Nothing against these guys. All very good players but not exactly the greatest of the great by any stretch.

I don't even know who a couple of those guys are so they must have been before my time. The point I'm making is the bar is different today than it was 20 years ago. Warren Moon could only be compared to the qbs during that time. Of course qbs today are gonna put up better numbers.

I met Curtis Martin this year. He wore his gold jacket. Nice guy. I thought he was a very good player but hall of fame was iffy I agree. Strahan is a shoe in bro. So is Tim Brown. Didn't that guy play offense and defense at times? Jayson Taylor, beast. Brian Dawkins is one of the most feared safeties of the last 20 years. Him and Ed Reed were both generational players.

You look at the hall of fame classes of the last few years, it's pretty insane the names that are there. Straight up all world players. I don't see even one mistake.

Last year we had: Tony Gonzales, Champ Bailey, Ed Reed, and Ty Law.

2018 had: Moss, Owens, Urlacher, Ray Lewis, and Dawkins.
So 2 of the 3 best WRs in history, and a top 2 MLB in NFL history, and probably a top 10 safety.

[MinnesotaFats]

Manning will be looked at less than: Brady, Brees, P Manning, Rodgers, Roethlisberger, Wilson.

Equal to: Luck, Rivers, Cousins, Stafford, Smith, Flacco, Ryan.

There's 5 dudes ahead of him for sure, 10 better QBs as contemporaries. I don't see him getting in w the stats.

The SBs aren't going to matter....Foles, Dilfer, Flacco all got rings

[2daBank]

Manning will be looked at less than: Brady, Brees, P Manning, Rodgers, Roethlisberger, Wilson.

Equal to: Luck, Rivers, Cousins, Stafford, Smith, Flacco, Ryan.

There's 5 dudes ahead of him for sure, 10 better QBs as contemporaries. I don't see him getting in w the stats.

The SBs aren't going to matter....Foles, Dilfer, Flacco all got rings

So care to bet? I’m not trying to win the is he deserving debate, he not in my HOF. You can bet your sweet ass he is in fact gonna be in the hof tho. It a lock.