Oh but you dead wrong. Pretty easy to prove. Just look at list of crappy QBs who have played in a super bowl!!
Care to tell me how good Rex Grossman was?
Can say Brad Johnson too with Tampa Bay.. Sure those teams had solid defenses but the QB's were smart enough to not blow it.. Still good thinking QB's regardless working to the teams strengths and understanding the game..
NOT OVERRATED!! Maybe suck in some areas a bit but everyone knew it.. Not overrated..
Comment
2daBank
SBR Aristocracy
01-26-09
88966
#38
Originally posted by JIBBBY
Can say Brad Johnson too with Tampa Bay.. Sure those teams had solid defenses but the QB's were smart enough to not blow it.. Still good thinking QB's regardless working to the teams strengths and understanding the game..
NOT OVERRATED!! Maybe suck in some areas a bit but everyone knew it.. Not overrated..
There a bunch of them, didn’t feel like listing them all since Grossman proved my point.
Comment
dlowilly
SBR Posting Legend
11-09-16
13862
#39
Originally posted by shocka1212
Prescott, Goff, Mayfield..
lol @ people saying Mariotta is overrated like theres anyone who thinks he's good in the first place.
That's why I said even though he isn't highly rated he's still rated too high
Comment
Bcatswin
SBR Posting Legend
12-21-10
13931
#40
Dalton if he is included, even though he has no line or receiving core. Guy still could never win a playoff game in like 5 or 6 tries. How he is a 4x Pro Bowler is beyond me.
Comment
wikkidinsane
SBR Posting Legend
05-30-10
13799
#41
Jimmy Garapollo
Matt Ryan
Baker Mayfield
Comment
wikkidinsane
SBR Posting Legend
05-30-10
13799
#42
Originally posted by pilebuck13
Jared Goff
Goff is not rated by anyone. so he is not overrated
Comment
wikkidinsane
SBR Posting Legend
05-30-10
13799
#43
Originally posted by gummo
Wentz
Prescott
Brees
Please take drew brees off this list.
Wentz we can argue
Prescott was overated for the first three fkin weeks of this season, so not valid. everyone thinks he sux.
Comment
JIBBBY
SBR Aristocracy
12-10-09
83686
#44
Originally posted by Bcatswin
Dalton if he is included, even though he has no line or receiving core. Guy still could never win a playoff game in like 5 or 6 tries. How he is a 4x Pro Bowler is beyond me.
You put Dalton on the Patriots and they win the Superbowl just like Brady.. Dalton can throw the ball with protection with the best of them.. Even the deep ball.. I'll say the same with Stanford on the Lions.. Give em time with a running game and they will dial it up off the play action pass!!!
Running game and offensive line is so BIG for QB ratings these days.. So many things to consider!!! Receiving core and play calling too..
Comment
Bcatswin
SBR Posting Legend
12-21-10
13931
#45
Originally posted by JIBBBY
You put Dalton on the Patriots and they win the Superbowl just like Brady.. Dalton can throw the ball with protection with the best of them.. Even the deep ball.. I'll say the same with Stanford on the Lions.. Give em time with a running game and they will dial it up off the play action pass!!!
Running game and offensive line is so BIG for QB ratings these days.. So many things to consider!!! Receiving core and play calling too..
Can't dispute that post.
Comment
GUMMO77
SBR Hall of Famer
08-23-10
9294
#46
Comment
jtoler
BARRELED IN @ SBR!
12-17-13
30967
#47
Originally posted by JIBBBY
You put Dalton on the Patriots and they win the Superbowl just like Brady.. Dalton can throw the ball with protection with the best of them.. Even the deep ball.. I'll say the same with Stanford on the Lions.. Give em time with a running game and they will dial it up off the play action pass!!!
Running game and offensive line is so BIG for QB ratings these days.. So many things to consider!!! Receiving core and play calling too..
with no a.j. green dalton cant buy a win. think him and stafford would find a way to not make super bowls with pats although Id take stafford over dalton
Comment
dmncnlou
SBR Wise Guy
02-17-11
924
#48
Green Bay QB
Saints QB
Overrated white boys who've played a zillion years with only 2 combined SB appearances
Comment
TheMoneyShot
BARRELED IN @ SBR!
02-14-07
28672
#49
You can't put Mahomes on that list... his ankle is absolutely fukked up at the moment...