If you put Prime Brady or Prime Peyton Manning on 2017 Browns,who gets better record?

[BigBusiness]

I've always wondered this. Start of the seasons at 0-0

Which QB gets that shytty team the most wins?

[PromiseLand]

Peyton- Smartest QB I've ever seen play the game.

[grease lightnin]

Prime Peyton has better regular season record, but loses in playoffs.

Prime Brady wins Super Bowl.

[CWD]

manning victim of patriots when they were cheating at high level

brady benefited from same cheating

manning easy

[jjgold]

Brady by far

[Snowball]

Manning throws like a girl compared to Brady.

[ikid2groove415]

Manning does a lot more then Brady - he runs the whole offense - king of audibles

[DrunkHorseplayer]

Manning by a mile.

[DwightShrute]

Is Belichick still the Browns' coach?

[Harry N. Lloyd]

manning victim of patriots when they were cheating at high level

brady benefited from same cheating

manning easy

Meow....

[ikid2groove415]

Can anyone ever remember manning offensive coach? Nope!! He was the offensive coach

[BrickJames]

How about some prime rib?

[19th Hole]

Wait...Wait...Wait...






I see Joe Montana coming into the picture.




.

[tony_come]

No question Manning is the guy

[GzaTheGenius]

Eli Manning

[newguy]

Everyone is right. Manning much better qb than Brady.

[GT21Megatron]

Everyone is right. Manning much better qb than Brady.

Dummy

[Hman]

Only reason i choose Manning is because he's proven he can succeed on different teams.

[DOM-Ganador]

Only reason i choose Manning is because he's proven he can succeed on different teams.

Patriots have proven over this run to be able to have success with totally different talent/schemes/coordinators.
Can`t go wrong with either guy.

[Master Bates]

Manning and it's not close

[19th Hole]

Looks like Manning's p.r. agent and his lukable advertising placements have erased any bad taste that the SBR faithful had in loveable Mr. Manning.

Tom Terrific has lost the sheen of the hero in the white hat after missing the golden ring.
Seems to be a lot of under the breath mummbling and grumbling.
$!#@ Patriots...%*€×+ Bellichick...@#&$! Brady.

Let me tell you P. Manning could not dust Brady's cleats no matter which team you want to place them on. Browns included.
(Montana over Manning also.)

[Monitor-Tan]

Brady's a 100% system QB, Manning EASY

[ikid2groove415]

Brady's a 100% system QB, Manning EASY

System? LOL

[ikid2groove415]

Brady made many more clutch throws when it matters - while manning often chokes - but talent wise manning has more

[lakerboy]

Regular season maybe Manning but not playoffs.

[Otters27]

Manning since he would be more of a player coach

[The J-Dizzle]

Manning since Brady wouldn't have Bellichick and McDaniels anymore.

[gojetsgomoxies]

to take a terrible team and make them fairly good, manning by far.

to take a good team and make them great, probably brady. definitely brady/bellichek