Have there been players like Aaron judge who sucked

[nyplayer33]

Had really good numbers..then quickly were nobody's.

[Bostongambler]

Joe Charboneau comes to mind.

[Rich Boy]

Vernon Wells - 1 year wonder

Cashed a huge contract then packed in his career

[2daBank]

Vernon Wells - 1 year wonder

Cashed a huge contract then packed in his career

He had several pretty good years didn't he?

[MinnesotaFats]

David McCarty

Kevin Moss

Bob Hamlin

Brady Anderson

Marcus Giles

Paul Sorrento

[jjgold]

good sell to the fans

He has to have decent year though and I say tougher to produce last years numbers

[Shute]

Dude has to find the hiitting zone
Too many strikeouts
If he can figure it out
Then greatness

[hawk 5]

Joe Charboneau comes to mind.

Got hit in head with fastball and never was the same. He would have been great

[Louisvillekid1]

Brady Anderson

lol what he have, like 51 from the lead off spot that year

[Louisvillekid1]

I’ll take Rick Ankiel & D Train, for the max Alex

[Clutchut12]

Brett boone

[slayer14]

Mark Prior if we are talking about pitching he had 1 good year then he struggled

[Louisvillekid1]

Yeah prior was mostly injuries tho

him and Kerry wood were sick that year

[Bostongambler]

Got hit in head with fastball and never was the same. He would have been great

Remember Tony Conigliaro? Had 100 home runs by age 22 then was hit in the face by a jack Hamilton pitch and he was never the same again. In fact since then on day games at Fenway they have a black tarp covering the seats in straight away centerfield so the hitters aren’t blinded by the pitch.

[Louisvillekid1]

Luis Gonzo

he went off one year , maybe 2-3 w/ zona

but was outta no where if I remember correctly

[jjgold]

If he hits 40 or more this year than could be legit power guy

Pressure on him and will be tough

[Clutchut12]

Mark Prior if we are talking about pitching he had 1 good year then he struggled

My favorite player,not even cubs fan but made sure i got his jersey back in the day. Went to pittaburg to see him play and he struck out i think 14 guys,he was dominate

[slayer14]

Darin Erstad never lived upto the hype

[Dilo]

Some of those guys played amazing baseball during the steroid era. Aaron judge might have some staying power, only if he’s clean though.

[Louisvillekid1]

Darin Erstad never lived upto the hype

Speaking of hype ,

the 2b from Seattle

Dustin ackley or w/e

what a bust

[ikid2groove415]

Judge is still young !! Relax!!

[krk1030]

im missing the part where judge is a nobody?

2nd in mvp as a rookie....

[pinnerpsk]

Darin Erstad never lived upto the hype

Darin Erstad had a damn good career. Look at his 2000 season:

He wound up with 240 hits, a franchise record, and batted .355 with 366 total bases, 121 runs scored and 25 home runs. Oh yeah, he also stole 28 bases and broke a major-league record with 100 RBIs while batting leadoff.

[GT21Megatron]

Kevin Maas?

[Underdog5229]

1 year wonder. 1st year goes big with the HR's but then teams scout and game plan around ur hot zone and figured out you cannot hit a high n tight fastball and game over. took the league a min to figure judge out. now he needs to actually get a good swing mechanics or hes riding bench

[Mr KLC]

Aaron Judge has as many (or more) homers on the season than the following teams:

• Indians
• Phillies
• Cardinals
• Nationals
• Marlins
• Brewers
• Diamondbacks

[eidolon]

Kevin Mitchell?

[jjgold]

He does not have a natural swing, it can break down real easy

Right now he is over powering the ball

Mitchell was good

[pologq]

chris davis deteriorated also but had multiple good seasons before stopping the juice.

[TATUMUS]

On the opposite end of the spectrum there's Bob Uecker....NEVER had good numbers, but became a baseball icon! (Career: 146 Hits | 167 SOs | WAR: -1) But an awesome guy!

28	MLN	NL	33	71	64	5	16	2	0	1	8	0	0	7	15	.250	.324	.328	.652	78	21	3	0	0	0	0	2H
29	MLN	NL	13	18	16	3	4	2	0	0	0	0	0	2	5	.250	.333	.375	.708	105	6	1	0	0	0	0	/H2
30	STL	NL	40	124	106	8	21	1	0	1	6	0	1	17	24	.198	.315	.236	.550	53	25	1	1	0	0	0	2
31	STL	NL	53	172	145	17	33	7	0	2	10	0	1	24	27	.228	.345	.317	.662	82	46	1	2	1	0	1	2/H
32	PHI	NL	78	237	207	15	43	6	0	7	30	0	0	22	36	.208	.279	.338	.617	71	70	8	0	4	4	6	2/H
33	TOT	NL	80	221	193	17	29	4	0	3	20	0	1	24	60	.150	.243	.218	.461	34	42	4	0	3	1	5	2H
33	PHI	NL	18	41	35	3	6	2	0	0	7	0	0	5	9	.171	.275	.229	.504	46	8	1	0	1	0	1	2/H
33	ATL	NL	62	180	158	14	23	2	0	3	13	0	1	19	51	.146	.236	.215	.451	31	34	3	0	2	1	4	2/H
297	843	731	65	146	22	0	14	74	0	3	96	167	.200	.293	.287	.581	63	210	18	3	8	5	12
162	460	399	35	80	12	0	8	40	0	2	52	91	.200	.293	.287	.581	63	115	10	2	4	3	7
108	269	238	22	43	6	0	4	21	0	1	28	71	.181	.266	.256	.522	49	61	7	0	2	1	4
96	278	242	18	49	8	0	7	37	0	0	27	45	.202	.278	.322	.601	68	78	9	0	5	4	7
93	296	251	25	54	8	0	3	16	0	2	41	51	.215	.332	.283	.615	70	71	2	3	1	0	1

[Mr KLC]

MLB doesn't have a face right now. Trust me, if Judge was walking down the street, average fans would go "damn he's tall; he's gotta be in the NBA"

[johnnyvegas13]

Kinda reminds me of A roid

i think judge is better tho