Is PATRICK WA the best goalie of all time?

[ronald]

Has to be Top 3 for sure, no?

[CWD]

van der saar but he choked in big games

[funnyb25]

Dominik Hasek. This would be hands down unanimous if he didn't get a late start to his career. He was the best

[Jayvegas420]

Brodeur, Dryden, then WA.
Bower & Cheevers bring up the rear.

[themike78]

It's Patrick Roy not Wa and yes he was the best.

[reigle9]

It's Patrick Roy not Wa and yes he was the best.

thanks Columbo

[klemopixx]

Got to throw Bernie Parent in the top 5. Two consecutive Cups, first one beating Cheevers. Would have won a third if not for an eye injury.

[MickeyMan]

You into French dudes Ronald?

[reigle9]

you guys don't have maf top 3?

[Dollars2Donuts]

Hasek
Brodeur
Roy
Essensa

mic drop

[Harry N. Lloyd]

Brodeur, Dryden, then WA.
Bower & Cheevers bring up the rear.

Cheevers wouldn't be considered in the top 50. Tretiak was as good as anyone but never played in the NHL.

[stevenash]

Marty was the greatest goalie to ever lace up the skates.

Even if you despised him, and a lot did, the most underrated goal keeper of all time was Billy Smith

[stevek173]

You can tell that spelling it "WA" as well as putting the name in caps is a desperate plea for attention.

[ThaWoj]

Roy was one of the greats. No such thing as a superstar goaltender anymore in the new Gary Bettman fan friendly high scoring nhl.

These were some of the great of the last 2 decades imo


Felix the cat
Cujo
Hasek
Olie the goalie
Richter
Brodeur
I'm not adding Belfour to this list but some might
I would add Grant fuhr too but most probably wouldnt

[Jayvegas420]

Belfor cujo & Felix...
Someone's blinded by Leafs blue!

[mdunlap3]

Definitely one of em. Always been a Brodeur guy myself.

[ronald]

You can tell that spelling it "WA" as well as putting the name in caps is a desperate plea for attention.

You're just bitter because you want IAG to put you on the JOSEPH GURNEY but she shut you down.

Sad.

[Stallion]

Yes.

[lakerboy]

Hated him. Guy was great though. I think at his peak nobody was better than the dominator. He had insane stats.

[steady hustlin]

When Brodeur was in the zone, as was often the case, I don't think it gets any better. Brodeur playing well > Roy playing well.

[TheMoneyShot]

Loved hockey back when Roy, Cujo, Hasek played....

I was always scared shi$less facing Roy. I would have to say Roy.

[ronald]

Met WA once in Toronto at MINK Nightclub, which was co-owned by former poster MATHDOTCOM for a short period of time.

[l3randonf]

Roy was a monster either way

[eidolon]

Goldberg

[lakerboy]

When Brodeur was in the zone, as was often the case, I don't think it gets any better. Brodeur playing well > Roy playing well.

Yes but Roy beat him in the head to head series. Roy went into the meadowlands in game 6 facing elimination and shut out the devils.

[DwightShrute]

Dominik Hasek. This would be hands down unanimous if he didn't get a late start to his career. He was the best

the best ever. Undisputed.

[eidolon]

Looking at hockey player ever, if you were to 'draft' a team, would you first draft Gretzky or the best goalie ever?

[Sam Losco]

hasek #1

[TheMoneyShot]

Hasek's mask when he was with Detroit. Funniest throat guard ever. Great goalie.

[nyplayer33]

Put lumquist in top 15 all time..the media adores him. Border no..he played goalie in a very defensive dystem..neutral zone trap. Patrick Roy great..hssek up there

[cankid]

Dominik Hasek. This would be hands down unanimous if he didn't get a late start to his career. He was the best

Followed pucks for 30yrs he was as shut down a goalie as any through all the yrs ... Despite not having the best teams he carried the Czech team and his NHL teams many times

[stevenash]

Looking at hockey player ever, if you were to 'draft' a team, would you first draft Gretzky or the best goalie ever?

Take away Messier and Gretzky isn't that great.

[nyplayer33]

How many saves does a top.goalie male vs a good.goalie..this is.very onpossible.to.figure. defense..oppomwnts.come into it.