2 Minute Drill In Peyton or Eli In their Prime?

[will2survive]

Simple question. We all know Peyton is one of the best quarterbacks ever, but in their prime and the game is on the line, I take Eli and I don't even think that it's close. You can say Eli has Beckham Jr. but he was a winner before ODB.

Any opinions?

[potjnr88]

Peyton...much better player. This nonsense about Peyton not being clutch late/in playoffs is a myth.

[TheMoneyShot]

Both players in their prime??

Easy... Peyton.

[MUHerd37]

Peyton. No doubt about it.

[sneakerhead]

Brady

[eidolon]

Eli had a 69 QB rating the year before Beckham was drafted. The two years with Beckham have been Eli's best years. People rave how good Beckham is as a WR, so it isn't a situation where the WR looks good because of a good QB.

[JameisBrady]

Peyton...much better player. This nonsense about Peyton not being clutch late/in playoffs is a myth.

...no it's not.


This thread shows why SBR is full of broke dick penetrates. Peyton clutch...lmao

[JameisBrady]

Eli has 2 of the top 4 highest graded passing performances in postseason history (by year) in terms of leveraged situations. He's literally as clutch as it gets.

[CMNoney]

Eli had a 69 QB rating the year before Beckham was drafted. The two years with Beckham have been Eli's best years. People rave how good Beckham is as a WR, so it isn't a situation where the WR looks good because of a good QB.

Eli won 2 SB's without Beckham. And he was the MVP in both those SB's.

Brady still has nightmares about Eli.

[MoMoneyMoVaughn]

Both guys are losers.

Shoulda stuck to fishin' skrimp.

[Eddy Munny]

Peyton Manning without hesitation. In his prime, PM was a Michael Jordan type of game changer.

Eli legally parks in the handicap space.

[beerman2619]

Eli clutch . Took a miracle catch by tyree in first super bowl. Nice drop by Welker in the second bowl vs pats. Peyton will be in the hall of fame. Eli not a bucking chance with his numbers. Eli 287 tds with 195 interceptions in career. Qb rating of 83. Peyton 539 tds with 251 ints qb rating of 96. Eli is a walking turnover jeb .

[tony_come]

Tim tebow

[beerman2619]

Eli has 2 of the top 4 highest graded passing performances in postseason history (by year) in terms of leveraged situations. He's literally as clutch as it gets.

eli as clutch as it gets. Could be the dumbest post I have ever seen on here. Eli with his 3rd int in the game. How many times have giants fans heard that plenty.

[CMNoney]

Eli will not only make the HOF, he will make it first ballot.

[zizoudane10]

In their prime?
Peyton, and it's not even close.

[tony_come]

Prime time Tim tebow

[zizoudane10]

Prime time Tim tebow

tonieste, no
I don't trust a guy that didn't want to bang Olivia Culpo

[tony_come]

tonieste, no
I don't trust a guy that didn't want to bang Olivia Culpo

Good point

[eidolon]

Eli won 2 SB's without Beckham. And he was the MVP in both those SB's.

Brady still has nightmares about Eli.

Eli is the luckiest QB ever. He is a Rex Grossman 2.0 but with luck on his side

[aston]

Peyton