Antonio Brown Or Beckham????

[jjgold]

Both impossible to stop although I still would take the Giant WR for one game

Beckham one of greatest I ever saw at his age

[Chi_archie]

Brown more proven

[Jeffie]

JJ stop, Brown is the best WR in this league and it's not close.

[Kermit]

Brown.

[gummo]

Brown is average without Ben. We don't know what Beckham can do without Manning.

[The Kraken]

Exactly, if Odell had a good QB he would break all records

[stealthyburrito]

Brown

[rm18]

Brown but neither is top 5

[mikemca]

Julio Jones

[mpaschal34]

Brown but neither is top 5

Huh????

I don't see 5 better than Antonio.

[afgballer56]

Calvin johnson
Julio jones
Aj Green
Antonio brown
Beckam
In no particular order

[rm18]

Jones, Green, Thomas, Dez, Hopkins

[FlipsideRM]

Jones, Green, Thomas, Dez, Hopkins

Is this a fuking joke? Take a lap pal

[rm18]

Brown is like 50 yards a game with Vick and JOnes.

[Scorpion]

Brown more proven

doesnt drop TD passes

[mpaschal34]

I'd take Brown over DT and certainly over Green.

[kidcudi92]

Beckham

[manny24]

Lafell

[Kermit]

Brown is like 50 yards a game with Vick and JOnes.

Brown had over 120 yards with Jones a couple weeks ago.

Vick and Jones' attempts were way lower than Ben's.

[KalouKalou]

Where is Watkins in your top 5

[The Giant]

Brown has the luxury of playing with a great quarterback, great running back, and great weapons all around him.

Beckham is better, and is four years younger.

Lots of rookies in this thread.

Michael Jack Corbin wins this one.

[Jeffie]

Brown has the luxury of playing with a great quarterback, great running back, and great weapons all around him.

Beckham is better, and is four years younger.

Lots of rookies in this thread.

Michael Jack Corbin wins this one.

Do you watch football? Or did you see a highlight of a one handed catch?

[The Giant]

Do you watch football? Or did you see a highlight of a one handed catch?

Do you watch football, or do you go by fantasy stats?

[Jeffie]

Do you watch football, or do you go by fantasy stats?

Fantasy means everything pal you know that.

[The Giant]

Fantasy means everything pal you know that.

While that's kind of true, I'm pretty sure if you polled all of the NFL GM's, most of them would take Beckham on their team.

[Kermit]

I'd like to see Beckham make the highlight reel with a move like this.

[mpaschal34]

Jones, Green, Thomas, Dez, Hopkins

Another top 5 performance by Green tonight.

[packerd_00]

I'd like to see Beckham make the highlight reel with a move like this.

Always can count on my boy Kermit to add some 80s nostalgia to the mix.

[SEAHAWKHARRY]

Think of what beckem could do with rivers

[FlipsideRM]

Another top 5 performance by Green tonight.

Yeah at least he held onto the ball on a pivotal 4th down. Almost cost the bengals a loss tonight

[JameisBrady]

Brown but neither is top 5

retards gonna retard.

[jjgold]

Brown is tough

Beckham is a fukkin freak though

[Ghenghis Kahn]

qbs make the receivers not the other way around.

good receivers are diamond dozen pal.

[Kermit]

qbs make the receivers not the other way around.

good receivers are diamond dozen pal.

Not sure that I agree with that entirely.

Anquan Boldin is responsible for Joe Flacco's fat payday that he received. And we all seen what happened after Flacco's receiving core was gone.

[Kermit]

Granted elite QBs can make a regular wide out into the top guy in the league, but if you don't have guys that can run routes properly, catch the ball, and give it everything that they have, it could be a short career for their QB.